THE JEWISH HOLOCAUST - WWI-WWII and what the European Red Cross did 2 destroy and continue 2 destroy the Jews today/
League of Nations 1928 was disbanded on the ashes of the Holocaust that shamed the world-and many troops broken hearted never told about the vicious cruelty of global politicians- FORMED UNITED NATIONS- WHO PROMISED 2 PROTECT THE JEWS... AND HUMANITY AND THE WORLD’S POOREST OF THE POOR... today??Canada and our Jews- from shame 2 grace.
WWII- Jews, Catholics, Gays, Lutherans, Gypsies, Disabled....BUTCHERED- Uncle Harold said- if the troops knew this it would have broken their hearts and tore their souls, he never got over it.
The "Final Solution"
Synopsis
The Nazis, under cover of the war, developed the technology, bureaucracy, and psychology of hate to efficiently murder millions of Jews. The details of the "Final Solution" were worked out at the Wannsee Conference. All Jews in Germany and the occupied countries were deported to sealed ghettos as a holding area. Many were then shipped in cattle cars to labor camps where they lived under brutally inhuman conditions. Hundreds of thousands were sent directly to the gas chambers in death camps. As the Allies advanced on the camps, death marches further depleted the ranks of potential camp survivors.
INSTRUCTIONAL OBJECTIVES
Students will learn that:
1. An entire state bureaucracy was mobilized solely for the purpose of annihilating Jews.
2. German technological expertise was harnessed to make the mass murder as efficient and low-cost as possible.
3. Special camps were created solely for the purpose of killing Jews and other "undesirables."
4. The conditions in these death camps and other concentration camps were brutal, and designed purposely to make survival only temporary.
CHAPTER CONTENT
On October 23, 1941, S.S. head Heinrich Himmler issued an order down the Nazi chain of command which heralded a major change in Nazi policy with respect to the "Jewish problem." Until then, the Nazis worked vigorously to encourage Jews to emigrate. The Madagascar Plan (see below) was one example of strategies which were formulated to remove Jews from Germany and its occupied lands. As is described in more detail in Chapter 11, many countries refused to accept Jewish refugees. This shift in policy resulted in the deportation of Jews to camps and ghettos in the East. The policy to "resettle" Jews to these ghettos and camps was a significant step in what was to become the "Final Solution" the systematic murder of millions of Jews.
Madagascar Plan
Before the "Final Solution" was devised to murder all Jews in Nazi jurisdiction, the scheme the Nazis planned to rid their land of the Jews was forced emigration. In 1940, plans were devised by the Nazis to ship all Jews under Nazi control to Madagascar, an island in the Indian Ocean. It was not until 1941 that Nazi bureaucrats were referring to the "Final Solution" (Gesamtlosung) in the context of genocide rather than a "Territorial Final Solution" (territoriale Endlosung) in the context of forced emigration. Some historians believe that the Madagascar Plan was a smokescreen for Hitler's desire to murder European Jewry (see page 62 of Marrus' The Holocaust in History).
Deportation
In response to this new "resettlement" policy, the first death camps were designed. Chelmno was the site of the first gassing of Jews, which occurred on December 8, 1941. The Nazi war machine had limited resources, including slave labor, much of it Jewish. Even so, the Nazis made a decision that the annihilation of the Jews of Europe was a more important achievement than the value of their labor. Similarly, the Nazis made a decision not to let the need for transport for the war effort interfere with the need for trucks and rail cars to carry the Jews to concentration camps and death centers. It was Adolf Eichmann who masterminded the logistics of the deportation of Jews. (1)
Deportation was the first step in the "Final Solution." Typically, the Jews were informed that they were going to be resettled for work. Each was told to take some clothing, blankets, shoes, eating utensils (but no knife), a bowl, and some money. Rounded up, they were herded into trucks for the trip to the rail station, or were forced to walk. The rail cars were often strategically located at a distance from the passenger terminals, so that this scene would not arouse the ire of the local populace. Many who did see chose not to protest.
The deportees were forced into rail cars, most of which were windowless, unheated cattle cars, and squeezed in so tightly that most were forced to stand. The doors were then sealed shut from the outside. Neither drinking water nor sanitary facilities were available. Each car held more than 120 people, and many froze or suffocated to death or succumbed to disease during the trip to the camps. The dead were not removed from the cars during the journey because the Nazi bureaucracy insisted that each body entering a car be accounted for at the destination.
(1) Adolph Eichmann
Transporting enough Jews to feed the death camps was a major logistical undertaking. The Nazi officer in charge of this duty was Adolph Eichmann, who traveled from country to country that was under German occupation to systematically plan the deportation of the local Jewish population to the death camps.
Eichmann received various levels of cooperation from each of the various occupied governments. But in countries such as Holland, Belgium, Albania, Denmark, Finland and Bulgaria, some Jews were saved from their deaths by the action of the sympathetic populace and government officials. Denmark's government and populace were exemplary in their heroism in saving Jews. In other countries such as Poland, Greece, France, and Yugoslavia, the deportation of Jews to the death camps was facilitated by the cooperation of the government.
Ghettoization (December 1939 to March 1942)
Although the Nazis were successful in isolating Jews socially and economically, the actual physical isolation of the Eastern European population did not begin until December 1939. Jews had known the ghetto since the Middle Ages, although Jews were then permitted to leave the ghetto during the day and participate in the business of the general community. The purpose of the Nazi ghetto, however, was to create a total confinement for the Jewish population, turning entire neighborhoods into a prison unlike the ghettos of centuries past.
The Nazis hoped that the wretched ghetto conditions would deplete the Jewish population quickly and naturally through starvation, disease and cold. The ghetto also served as the holding area for eventual transport to the death camps for those who were able to survive.
Ghetto inhabitants in many areas were forced to become slaves for German industry. Factories were built alongside or within ghetto walls so that industries could take advantage of this free labor. The administration of Jewish life was the responsibility of the Jewish Councils, the Judenröte (see Chapter 11).
Life in the ghetto was abominable, and thousands died. There was no medicine. The food ration allowed was a quarter of that available for the Germans, barely enough to allow survival. The water supply was contaminated in many ghettos. Epidemics of tuberculosis, typhoid, and lice were common. Bodies of new victims piled up in the streets faster than they could be carted away. In the Warsaw ghetto, more than 70,000 died of exposure, disease, and starvation during the first two winters. Almost all of those who survived the Warsaw ghetto were either killed when the ghetto was razed in 1943 or died in the death camps.
Theresienstadt Ghetto
The Theresienstadt ghetto was established by the Nazis in an 18th century fortress in Czechoslovakia on November 24, 1941. More than 150,000 Jews passed through the ghetto during its four-year existence, which was used as a holding area for eventual murder in Auschwitz. By 1943, rumors began circulating in the international community that the Nazis were exterminating Jews in gas chambers, and that the conditions of the ghettos did not permit survival. The Nazis rebuilt parts of this ghetto to serve as a "showpiece" for propaganda purposes. Flower gardens were planted in the ghetto. Shops, schools, and a cafe were built. When an investigating commission of the International Red Cross came to visit, they did not see a typical ghetto. In July 1944 the Nazis made a documentary propaganda film about life in this ghetto. After the movie was completed, most of the Jewish "actors" were shipped to their death at Auschwitz.
Wannsee Conference
At the Wannsee Conference on January 20, 1942 in Wannsee, a Berlin suburb, the details of the "Final Solution" were worked out. The meeting was convened by Reinhard Heydrich, who was the head of the S.S. main office and S.S. Chief Heinrich Himmler's top aide. The purpose of the meeting was to coordinate the Nazi bureaucracy required to carry out the "Final Solution," which provided for:
Deportation of Jews to killing centers.
Immediate death for those who were unable to work or the very young, the old, and the weak.
Segregation by gender of the remaining Jews.
Decimation through forced labor with insufficient nourishment.
Eventual death for the remnant.
Concentration Camps
The Nazi concentration camps were established beginning in 1933 for the purpose of imprisoning political opponents. After the "Night of the Long Knives" (see Chapter 8, page 65), authority and management of the concentration camps was turned over to the S.S. The S.S. expanded the concentration camp system, and used these facilities to warehouse other "undesirables," including hundreds of thousands of Jews. Dachau, Buchenwald and Sachsenhausen were among the first concentration camps built by the Nazis near Munich, Weimar, and Berlin respectively.
Upon arrival at a camp, the inmates were usually stripped of all their valuables and clothes. They were then shorn of body hair, disinfected, given a shower, and issued a striped prison uniform without regard to size. Each step of the process was designed to dehumanize the prisoners, both physically and emotionally. Each prisoner was given a number. At Auschwitz, for example, the number was tattooed on the arm, but some camps did not tattoo their inmates.
Life in the camps was a living hell. As described by Judah Pilch in "Years of the Holocaust: The Factual Story," which appears in The Jewish Catastrophe in Europe, a typical day in the life of a concentration camp inmate began at dawn, when they were roused from their barracks which housed 300-800 inmates each. Their "beds" were bunks of slatted wood two and three tiers high. Frequently three to four prisoners shared each bunk, not permitting space enough for them to stretch out for normal sleep. The inmates were organized into groups to go to the toilets, marched to a distribution center for a breakfast consisting of some bread and a liquid substitute for tea or coffee, and then sent out to work for 10-14 hours in mines, factories, and road or airfield building, often in sub-zero weather or the severe heat of summer. They were subjected to constant physical and emotional harassment and beating. The inmates' food rations did not permit survival for very long. Those who resisted orders of the guards were shot on the spot. Numerous roll calls were held to assure that no prisoners had escaped. If one did attempt an escape, all of the inmates suffered for it.
Death Camps
The German skill in adapting the 20th century techniques of mass production was applied in engineering the "Final Solution." In 1941, the engineers of the "Final Solution" utilized these same principles to cheaply and efficiently murder millions of Jews and other "undesirables." The plants established to carry out this mass murder were the death camps.
Unlike concentration camps, death camps had no barracks to house prisoners, other than those for workers at the camps. In order to process the murder of thousands of people, great pains were taken to deceive the victims concerning their fate. Jews deported from ghettos and concentration camps to the death camps were unaware of what they were facing. The Nazi planners of the operation told the victims that they were being resettled for labor, issued them work permits, told them to bring along their tools and to exchange their German marks for foreign currency. Food was also used to coax starving Jews onto the trains. Once the trains arrived at the death camps, trucks were available to transport those who were too weak to walk directly to the gas chambers. The others were told that they would have to be deloused and enter the baths. The victims were separated by sex and told to remove their clothes. The baths were in reality the gas chambers. The shower heads in the baths were actually the inlets for poison gas. At Auschwitz, the gas chambers held 2,000 people at a time. With the introduction of a cyanide-based gas called Zyklon B, all 2,000 occupants could be killed in five minutes. As a result of this technological "advancement," Auschwitz was able to "process" the death of 12,000 victims daily. Before the bodies were removed by workers with gas masks and burned in crematoria, the teeth of the victims were stripped for gold, which was melted down and shipped back to Germany. Innocent victims were exploited and desecrated to a degree unknown in human history.
Unlike the death camps of Treblinka, Chelmno, Sobibor, and Belzec, which were built and operated solely to kill Jews, the two death camps of Maidanek and Auschwitz also had a work camp attached. Upon arrival at these two camps, a selection was made at the train station concerning which Jews (about 10 percent of the arrivals) would be permitted to live and escape immediate gassing in the gas chambers. These "lucky" survivors were permitted to live only to the extent that they endured the physical and emotional trauma inflicted upon them. They were given a food ration that permitted them to survive for only three months. As they died from exhaustion, beatings, and starvation, they were replaced with newly arrived victims. Auschwitz was also used as the site for medical experimentation. Many of these experiments had little scientific value but were only exercises to discover how much torture a victim could endure until death. By the end of 1944, an estimated two-and-a-half million Jews had died at Auschwitz. More than a quarter of a million Gypsies also died there.
Einsatzgruppen or "Special Action Squads"
Specially trained units of the S.S. followed the first wave of German army troops in the invasion of the Soviet Union (June 1941). Their orders were to execute on the spot all Communists, Jews, and Gypsies.
It is estimated that by the end of 1942, they had killed more than a million Soviet Jews. These victims were shot or loaded into enclosed trucks modified for the introduction of carbon monoxide to asphyxiate its victims. An additional 400,000 were killed by other S.S. units, anti-Semitic native civilians, police units, and the German army.
Babi Yar
The Jews of Kiev were rounded up by the Einsatzgruppen for "resettlement" in late September 1941. Thousands of Jews were brought to a ravine on the outskirts of Kiev and mowed down by machine guns. Many who were not wounded, including thousands of children, were thrown into the pit of bodies and were buried alive. According to an account in The Holocaust by Martin Gilbert, Ukrainian militia men joined in the slaughter. The records of the Einsatzgruppen unit which participated in the executions recorded 33,771 Jews killed at Babi Yar on September 29-30. In all, more than 100,000 persons, most of them Jews, were executed at Babi Yar between 1941-1943 by the Nazis. In the summer of 1943, the bodies were dug out by slave labor and burned to hide the evidence of the slaughter.
Nazi Murder of Non-Jews
While the focus of Nazi genocide was unquestionably targeted toward Jews, the Third Reich's policy of mass murder was not restricted to Jews but devastated the ranks of other non-Aryans.
Michael R. Marrus, in his book, The Holocaust in History, writes about the targets of Nazi murder:
"The Nazis murdered between five million and six million Jews during the Holocaust, two-thirds of European Jewry and about one-third of the entire Jewish people. But a staggering 55 million may have perished in all theaters during the Second World War including some 20 million Soviet citizens...five million Germans, and three million non-Jewish Poles...In all, some 18 million European civilians may have died as a result of famine, disease, persecution, and more conventional acts of war.
"Awesome as they are, therefore, numbers do not in themselves prescribe the singularity of the Holocaust. But they provide a clue. For the proportion of European Jews killed during the Second World War, with roughly one of every three civilian deaths in Europe being that of a Jew, was undoubtedly greater than that of any other people, because of the Nazis' policy toward them. Unlike the case with any other group, and unlike the massacres before or since, every single one of the millions of targeted Jews was to be murdered. Eradication was to be total. In principle, no Jew was to escape. In this important respect, the Nazis' assault upon Jewry differed from the campaigns against other peoples and groups; Gypsies, Jehovah's Witnesses, homosexuals, Poles, Ukrainians, and so on. Assaults on these people could indeed be murderous; their victims number in the millions, and their ashes mingle with those of the Jews of Auschwitz and many other camps across Europe. But Nazi ideology did not require their total disappearance. In this respect, the fate of the Jews was unique."
Gypsies
Approximately a half million Gypsies (a dark-skinned, Caucasian ethnic group targeted by the Nazis) were murdered out of approximately 1.6 million who were living in Europe. The Gypsies in Germany and the occupied territories of the German War machine were subjected to many of the same persecutions as the Jews: restrictive, discriminatory laws, isolation and internment, and mass executions at their camp sites, in labor camps and death camps.
Polish Christians
Of the six million Poles murdered by the Nazis, half were Polish Christians. The Nazis considered the Poles and other Slavic peoples to be sub-human destined to serve as slaves to the Aryan "master race." The Polish intelligentsia and political leadership was sought out specifically for execution, and other Polish civilians were slaughtered indiscriminately. Among the dead were more than 2,600 Catholic priests.
Ukrainians
Almost four million Ukrainians fell victim to Nazi slaughter, through combat, starvation, and terror, particularly as a result of the efficient Einsatzgruppen. Of these, 900,000 were Jews, according to Bohdan Wytwychky's The Other Holocaust: Many Circles of Hell.
Other Victims of Nazi Genocide
The Germans rounded up thousands of Jehovah's Witnesses and homosexuals and sent them to the death camps for extermination. Homosexuals were forced to wear pink triangles on their clothing paralleling the yellow Star of David for Jews.
Death Marches
By the beginning of 1945, the Soviet troops were advancing through Poland. The retreating Germans forced all remaining Auschwitz prisoners to march toward Germany under indescribably cruel conditions. Approximately 20,000 of 58,000 prisoners died en route, from exhaustion, starvation, cold, beatings, and executions by guards.
In his bunker, in the Chancellory building in Berlin, knowing that the war was lost and that the "1,000 Year Reich" had lasted only a few years, Hitler committed suicide hours after marrying Eva Braun. Germany formally surrendered to the Allies on May 7, 1945. By the end of the war, more than 55 million had died and 35 million wounded. Only 17 million of the dead were soldiers.
Historical Events Listing
April 9, 1940 - Germany invaded and occupied Denmark.
April 27, 1940 - Himmler ordered the establishment of a concentration camp at Auschwitz.
April 30, 1940 - The ghetto at Lodz, Poland, was sealed off.
June 4, 1940 - Germany invaded Holland, Belgium, and France.
June 29, 1940 - Marshal Petain surrenders France to the Germans.
September 27, 1940 - The Berlin-Rome-Tokyo Axis was established.
September 27, 1940 - The Warsaw Ghetto was sealed off, making thousands of Jews inside virtual prisoners under house arrest.
June 22, 1941 - Germany invaded Greece and Yugoslavia.
June 22, 1941 - The Germans attacked and declared war on the Soviet Union.
July 8, 1941 - Wearing of the Jewish Star was decreed in the German-occupied Baltic states.
July 31, 1941 - S.S. Obergruppenführer Reinhard Heydrich was appointed by Goering to carry out the "Final Solution", the murder of all the Jews in Europe.
September 1, 1941 - Wearing of the Jewish "Star of David" was decreed throughout the Greater Reich.
October 1, 1941 - All Jewish emigration was halted.
October 14, 1941 - Mass deportation to concentration camps of Jews from all over Nazi-controlled Europe began.
December 8, 1941 - 27,000 were massacred in Riga.
October 23, 1941 - 34,000 were massacred in Odessa.
October 28, 1941 - 34,000 were massacred in Kiev.
November 6, 1941 - 15,000 were massacred in Rovno.
December 7, 1941 - The Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor. The United States entered the war.
December 8, 1941 - Chelmno death camp on the Ner River in Poland opened and the first gassing took place.
December 11, 1941 - Germany declared war on the United States.
October 17, 1942 - The Allied Nations pledged to punish the Germans for their policy of genocide.
Winter of 1943 - The tattered and frozen German army on the Eastern front surrendered to the Soviets at Stalingrad.
April 1943 - The Bermuda Conference on Refugees was convened. The agenda was to discuss action by the Allies to rescue refugees in Europe under Nazi control. No formal action was agreed to.
October 7, 1943 - Hitler ordered that all Jews of Denmark be deported to the death camps in Poland. Almost 95% of Danish Jews were whisked to Sweden, escaping the S.S.
March 18, 1944 - The Germans invaded and occupied Hungary. Deportations of Hungarian Jews to Auschwitz followed under the direction of Adolf Eichmann. Mostly all of the half-million Hungarian Jews were sent to the gas chambers.
June 1, 1944 - D-Day. The Allies invaded France at Normandy.
VOCABULARY
Auschwitz - The most infamous and largest of the Nazi death camps, located near Cracow in Southwestern Poland.
Babi Yar - An area in the Soviet Union near Kiev, where thousands of civilians, most of whom were Jews, were murdered by the Nazis.
crematorium - An oven where the bodies of newly murdered prisoners of camps, and those who died from other causes, were incinerated.
death camps - Centers established in mostly rural areas designed specifically for mass murder. Six death camps (Auschwitz, Treblinka, Sobibor, Maidanek, Chelmno and Belzec) were established solely for the extermination of European Jewry.
death marches - Forced marches under brutal conditions required of death camp and concentration camp inmates by the Nazis to avoid liberation by advancing Allied forces.
Einsatzgruppen - "Special Action Squads" of the S.S. which had as their mission to seek out and murder Jews, Communists and Gypsies.
extermination - Mass murder, in the context of the killing of Jews in a manner which would be no less heinous than the killing of insects.
Final Solution - The term used by the Nazis to describe their program of mass murder of the Jewish people.
gas chamber - Rooms constructed to be air-tight so that poison gas introduced into the room would kill large numbers of people.
Gypsies - A dark-skinned, Caucasian ethnic group with origins in India who had, in many cases in Europe, a migratory way of life.
labor camp - A prison camp where the prisoners were used as slave labor for German industry and war machine.
tuberculosis - An infectious disease which can affect any organ, but particularly attacks the lungs.
typhus - Disease transmitted by lice or fleas which was epidemic in concentration camps.
zyklon B - A cyanide gas developed to kill Jews at Auschwitz in a manner which was more efficient than using carbon monoxide gas.
ACTIVITIES
Research the average daily calorie intake of people in the United States and the developing world, and compare this to the average intake of a concentration camp inmate.
Research why the Nazis kept detailed chronicles of all aspects of their genocide.
Research the story of "The Precious Legacy." What did the Nazis have in mind by creating this exhibit?
Define the following words using their dictionary definition, and construct another definition, using the Nazi context if appropriate:
murder massacre euthanasia mass-murder slaughter liquidation
deportation assassination pogrom decimation execution terrorism
killing extermination persecution genocide holocaust
What do these words have in common? Which words above are interchangeable?
Which are euphemisms? Which may be condoned (and under what circumstances) and which may not? Why is there sensitivity among scholars and survivors of the Holocaust on how these words are used?
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Discuss what you would have taken into a ghetto had you been deported to one.
How did the Nazis succeed in carrying out the Final Solution? Why were the orders from the top obeyed all the way down the chain of command?
EVALUATION
1. Define the following:
zyklon B
crematorium
"special treatment"
labor camp
gas chamber
Final Solution
typhus
Gypsies
2. Describe life in the Nazi ghettos for the Jews and the major differences between these ghettos and those of the Middle Ages.
3. What was the mission of the Einsatzgruppen? Who were their targets? What methods did they use to accomplish their mission?
4. Who was Adolf Eichmann, and what was his job?
5. How was the Theresienstadt ghetto in Czechoslovakia different than any other ghetto?
6. Name three death camps, and briefly describe typical conditions in one.
7. What was the Wannsee Conference? Who convened it? What was its purpose?
8. What prompted the Nazis to order the "death marches" of 1945?
9. Why were experiments performed on inmates of the death camps?
TEACHING STRATEGIES
Show the class the book and filmstrip, I Never Saw Another Butterfly.
Recreate the discussions on human nature and values from previous chapters. Let the students describe if their views on human nature have changed as a result of learning about what occurred during the "Final Solution."
Have students view the film, The Wannsee Conference. Study guides on this film are available (contact the Holocaust Resource Center nearest you).
Read to the class poignant excerpts from Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank.
http://remember.org/guide/Facts.root.final.html
I NEVER SAW ANOTHER BUTTERFLY
Studio East presents "I Never Saw Another Butterfly" October 5-13, directed by Lani Brockman and musically direct by Laura Shepherd. Book by Celeste Raspanti, Original Music by Susan Bardsley.
I Never Saw Another Butterfly is a story based on the lives and art of Jewish children held in Terezin during WWII and the Holocaust. Please be aware of the emotional nature of this show and the subject matter it faces.
Over 15,000 Jewish children passed through the Terezin concentration camp during WWII, and only about a hundred were alive when Terezin was liberated. Raja lived through it all, teaching the children when there was nothing to teach with, helping to give them hope when there was little reason for hope. This play is her story. It is history as much as any play can be history, showing the best and the worst of which the human heart is capable of. Recommended for ages 9 and up.
Special Thanks to Gwyneth for her cinematic help and those interviewed (Xana Waughman, Kaleena Jordan, Sienna Kitch, Sean Ben-Zvi, Caia Bornfreund, and Sarina Leon).
Songs featured: "I Never Saw Another Butterfly", "Go Away Alone"
CANADA MILITARY
NEWS-Jan 27/15-
ISRAEL- THE JEWS- WWI-WWII and what the
European Red Cross did 2 destroy and continue 2 destroy the Jews today/ League
of Nations 1928 was disbanded on the ashes of the Holocaust that shamed the
world-and many troops broken hearted never told about the vicious cruelty of
global politicians- FORMED UNITED NATIONS- WHO PROMISED 2 PROTECT THE JEWS...
AND HUMANITY AND THE WORLD’S POOREST OF THE POOR... today??Canada and our Jews-
from shame 2 grace. WWII- Jews, Catholics, Gays, Lutherans, Gypsies,
Disabled.... Uncle Harold said- if the troops knew this it would have broken
their hearts and tore their souls, he never got over it.
-------------
1.
[PDF]
immigrants, my
grandmother, a German of Jewish origin who came to Canada from Denmark with her husband
and three children in 1955. Käthe Therese ...
---------------
|
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yLSvdEUA2wI8
Jul 2010 - 3
min - Uploaded
by Anne Frank House
The biography tells the story of Anne Frank's life, and ends with the return of O... ... It makes me ... |
---------------
www.annefrankguide.net/en-ca/bronnenbank.asp?oid=271642 - Cached
- SimilarEven
the story of Anne Frank has Canadian links. Canadian
troops took part in
liberating the Netherlands (where Anne Frank lived for the longest period of her ...
liberating the Netherlands (where Anne Frank lived for the longest period of her ...
------------------
news.moviefone.com/2014/01/09/alfred-hitchcock-abandoned... Cached
Jan 09,
2014 · A long-abandoned Holocaust documentary made by Alfred Hitchcock
shortly after World War II concentration camps were ... These are the movies
you’re ...
--------------
Every one -especially students globally should watch this documentary and learn about humanity...
An Alfred Hitchcock documentary on the Nazi Holocaust
BEST COMMENT:
I've got no time for
people trying to justify or play down this horror. I don't care if you think
its propaganda or if America, russian or the little green men from mars have
done the same. The bottom line is its wrong. No human whether they support the
left or right, white, black, brown or bright purple, we should never treat
another person or living thing like this. I'm not a hippy or lefty just someone
who gets so depressed by how greedy, nasty, abusive and manipulative the human
race is. This kinda of thing happens all to often in the name of some non
existent god or fear of someone they haven't taken the time to understand. Sick
of self righteous conspiracy theorist who try to side step or give some sort of
answer to this type of action. Its wrong pure and simple
--------------
Alfred Hitchcock's Abandoned Holocaust Documentary Gets Release
Posted January 9th, 2014
A long-abandoned Holocaust documentary made by Alfred
Hitchcock shortly after World War II concentration camps were liberated in 1944
will finally see the light of day.
The Independent reports that the documentary, called "Memory of the Camps," will air later this year on British television, as well as screen at several film festivals and theaters, to commemorate the 70th anniversary of Europe's liberation. It was shown once in on PBS in 1984, but was missing one of its six reels and in poor condition; the new version has been remastered and contains some recovered portions of the lost reel.
"Memory of the Camps" was commissioned in part to help drive home to the German people the atrocities committed by the Nazis, and force the country to take responsibility for those actions. Hitchcock was brought on as a director and was tasked with piecing together footage shot by the British Army Film Unit, including the liberation of Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in 1945.
But Hitchcock was so disturbed by what he saw that he had trouble finishing the film; he reportedly refused to return to Pinewood Studios for a week because of the horrifying footage. Work on the documentary was slow and tedious, and was soon scrapped all together, after its benefactors realized that its impact would be lessened by the rapidly-changing political climate. Five "Memory of the Camps" reels were left to the British Imperial War Museum, untouched until the early 1980s.
Toby Haggith, senior curator at the Imperial War Museum's Department of Research, said the documentary will be renamed before its public screenings later this year. Recent test screenings revealed that the footage was still "extremely disturbing" all these years later, he said.
"One of the common remarks was that it [the film] was both terrible and brilliant at the same time," Haggith said. " ... We can't stop the film being incredibly upsetting and disturbing, but we can help people understand why it is being presented in that way."
The Independent reports that the documentary, called "Memory of the Camps," will air later this year on British television, as well as screen at several film festivals and theaters, to commemorate the 70th anniversary of Europe's liberation. It was shown once in on PBS in 1984, but was missing one of its six reels and in poor condition; the new version has been remastered and contains some recovered portions of the lost reel.
"Memory of the Camps" was commissioned in part to help drive home to the German people the atrocities committed by the Nazis, and force the country to take responsibility for those actions. Hitchcock was brought on as a director and was tasked with piecing together footage shot by the British Army Film Unit, including the liberation of Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in 1945.
But Hitchcock was so disturbed by what he saw that he had trouble finishing the film; he reportedly refused to return to Pinewood Studios for a week because of the horrifying footage. Work on the documentary was slow and tedious, and was soon scrapped all together, after its benefactors realized that its impact would be lessened by the rapidly-changing political climate. Five "Memory of the Camps" reels were left to the British Imperial War Museum, untouched until the early 1980s.
Toby Haggith, senior curator at the Imperial War Museum's Department of Research, said the documentary will be renamed before its public screenings later this year. Recent test screenings revealed that the footage was still "extremely disturbing" all these years later, he said.
"One of the common remarks was that it [the film] was both terrible and brilliant at the same time," Haggith said. " ... We can't stop the film being incredibly upsetting and disturbing, but we can help people understand why it is being presented in that way."
--------------------
Inside Alfred Hitchcock’s Lost Holocaust Documentary
In 1945, Britain’s army film unit commissioned a sprawling
doc on the liberation of Nazi concentration camps, supervised by Hitchcock. A
new film explores the forgotten masterpiece.
It is, perhaps, the greatest documentary never made.Back in 1945, Sidney Bernstein, the chief of the Psychological Warfare Film Section of the Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force, was commissioned to create the definitive documentary chronicling the liberation of the Nazi concentration camps. Bernstein’s aim was, in his words, to “prove one day that this had actually happened” and have it serve as “a lesson to all mankind as well as to the Germans.”
He eventually roped in his good pal, Alfred Hitchcock, to serve as the film’s supervising director. But the horrifying and heartbreaking footage of numerous concentration camps, shot by British, American, and Russian World War II soldiers as they were being liberated, became tangled up in a complicated web of politics and artistic rows. A magnificent new HBO documentary pulls back the veil on the making of German Concentration Camps: Factual Survey.
The eye-opening film-on-a-film, Night Will Fall, will premiere January 27 on HBO. It is narrated by Helena Bonham Carter, produced by Stephen Frears and Brett Ratner, and directed by Andre Singer, who serves as president of The Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and executive produced the documentaries The Act of Killing and Werner Herzog’s Into the Abyss. It was done in concert with London’s Imperial War Museum, and took 18 months of poring over thousands of feet of film to trace the making of the unmade epic.
“Neat and tidy orchards. Well-stocked farms lined the
wayside. And the British soldier did not fail to admire the place, and its
inhabitants—at least, until he began to feel a smell...”
“When I first saw material, it was shattering to see; a horrific
experience,” Singer tells The Daily Beast. “I’ve been in the film world a long
time and seen lots and lots of footage and you think you’ll get anesthetized to
it, but that isn’t the case. This is something that is once seen, never
forgotten.”Singer’s documentary opens with footage from German Concentration Camps: Factual Survey of the British 11th Armoured Division liberating the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in Northern Germany on April 15, 1945. There, the Allied troops discovered a strange sight.
“Neat and tidy orchards. Well-stocked farms lined the wayside. And the British soldier did not fail to admire the place, and its inhabitants—at least, until he began to feel a smell,” says a narrator in voiceover.
The British soldiers found tens of thousands of emaciated prisoners inside the camp, many of which were on the brink of death by starvation. The camera lingers on piles of naked, skeletal corpses stacked several bodies high, as well as line after line of dead children. A total of 30,000 corpses were witnessed by Allied troops, according to the film. Singer managed to track down several British soldiers who were there, and some break down in tears recalling the horrors.
“It’s very difficult to describe,” recalls survivor Anita Lasker-Wallfisch, who was 19 when Bergen-Belsen was liberated. “You’ve spent years preparing yourself to die, and you’re still here. Every British soldier looked like a God to us.”
“We opened one warehouse. Women’s hair,” says Matvey Gershman, a member of the Soviet’s 8th Guards Army at Majdanek. “We opened the second warehouse. Children’s shoes. The third warehouse, something else: Zyklon gas in barrels. And ashes, ashes. They stored people’s ashes the way they stored women’s hair.”
Footage from Bernstein’s documentary shows Russian soldiers opening stacks of large packages the size of duffle bags and removing piles of human hair, as the camera rests on a young girl’s ponytail amid the pile in close-up. You see crematoriums filled with ashes, still burning, and long rows of human bones.
Also included is footage of the Russian liberation of Auschwitz, including a fascinating sequence wherein Soviet soldiers are captured clad in white, camouflaged snowcoats crawling across the wintry tundra towards the Nazi death camp while clenching ski poles, with skis attached to their feet. Eva Mozes Kor, a survivor of the sadistic Mengele experiments, tears up watching footage of her younger self being freed from captivity.
American soldiers, meanwhile, captured the liberation of Buchenwald and Dachau, and since American films began using 16mm color footage in January 1945, Bernstein’s film includes haunting color shots of heaps of withered corpses at Buchenwald, as well as shrunken Jewish heads inside jars. The American troops made local German citizens from the nearby city of Weimar visit the camp and witness the genocide firsthand. A German woman is seen fainting and being carried away, while other women casually turn their heads away in disgust.
“They had been aware of the camp and had been willing to make use of the cheap labor it provided—as long as they were beyond smelling range of it,” the narrator says.
While Bernstein’s opus was first commissioned in April 1945, it wasn’t until June that his pal, “The Master of Suspense” Alfred Hitchcock, came onboard after being released from his Hollywood duties. “I had felt that I needed at least to make some contribution,” Hitchcock says in an interview from 1962. “There wasn’t any question of military service—I was overage and overweight at that time—but nevertheless, I felt the urge.”
Since Bernstein was only given three months to complete the film, by the time June rolled around, he felt the need to recruit Hitch to help him piece it together. “Bernstein knew he needed some leverage,” says Singer. “He thought if they had a big name director it would help not just because it was better for the film, but it would give credibility to the film.”
So, Hitchcock served as a “director’s advisor,” supervising the way the footage was edited. He demanded that the documentary emphasized long shoots and frequent pans, so that people wouldn’t question its authenticity. He was also blown away by the stark contrast between the quotidian (the lives of Germans living near the camps) and the ghastly (the nightmare within), and requested that the film use maps to highlight their proximity, driving home the message that these German citizens knew exactly what was going on.
“Hitchcock himself is reputed to have been very nauseated by the footage,” says Singer. “He saw it in the cutting room and then didn’t want to watch it again.”
Bernstein’s time, however, soon ran out. According to a June 1945 memo from the Psychological Warfare Film department, Bernstein, lost in an artistic quagmire, was relieved of his duties. “Here he was trying to make a propaganda film, and he ended up making a great documentary,” says Singer. “And that’s not really what the government wanted.”
The Americans then installed acclaimed Double Indemnity filmmaker Billy Wilder as supervising director, and used some of Bernstein’s footage to create a short propaganda film entitled Death Mills. Whereas Bernstein’s film was artistic and captured the full breadth of suffering, Wilder’s version is described as a “hectoring short film” that “merely accused the Germans of committing these crimes.” Still, to the Americans’ credit, the film premiered in Germany.
“We must show it to as many Germans as possible,” Wilder says in a 1988 interview. “They will say: it’s a lie. These are extras with makeup. This is Hollywood… made by Jews. But where would we have got them from? They were just skin and bone!”
While Bernstein’s footage was eventually used as evidence against Nazi officials during the Nuremberg trials, his original, uncensored vision never saw the light of day. Singer’s film claims that the British government chose to kill Bernstein’s comprehensive documentary largely for two reasons. First, that Britain didn’t want to “further alienate the German people,” who were in a rebuilding phase and, with hints of the Cold War starting to appear, were seen as a potentially ally against the Soviets. And second, that the British were worried about the budding Zionist movement and weren’t interested in galvanizing support for a Jewish state.
“I don’t think that in government they were concerned about whether the German people were denying it ever happened,” Singer says of the film’s cancellation. “Morally and ethically it should be done, but in practical terms, it was just bad, bad timing. Churchill had just been kicked out of government and was more sympathetic, and there was a new foreign secretary, Ernest Bevin, who was virulently anti-Zionist. I don’t think it was a conspiracy, or that any censorship was going on.”
As for his own documentary Night Will Fall, Singer feels it’s vital to inform audiences of what really happened at the Nazi concentration camps in order for the wounds of the past to heal, but not be forgotten.
“A lot of people are worried about whether we should be showing atrocity footage like this to people, is it meant to shock, and is there a pornography element to it,” says Singer. “I believe the opposite. Put in context, it’s incredibly important.”
------------
Holocaust Denial Timeline
WHAT IS HOLOCAUST DENIAL?
The Holocaust is one of the best documented events in history. “Holocaust denial” describes attempts to negate the established facts of the Nazi genocide of European Jewry. Common denial assertions are: that the murder of six million Jews during World War II never occurred; that the Nazis had no official policy or intention to exterminate the Jews; and that the poison gas chambers in Auschwitz-Birkenau death camp never existed.
A newer trend is the distortion of the facts of the Holocaust. Common distortions include, for example, assertions that: the figure of six million Jewish deaths is an exaggeration; deaths in the concentration camps were the results of disease or starvation but not policy; and that the diary of Anne Frank is a forgery.
Holocaust denial and distortion are generally motivated by hatred of Jews, and build on an accusation that the Holocaust was invented or exaggerated by Jews as part of a plot to advance Jewish interests. This view perpetuates long-standing antisemitic stereotypes by accusing Jews of conspiracy and world domination, hateful charges that were instrumental in laying the groundwork for the Holocaust.
The United States Constitution ensures freedom of speech. Therefore, in the United States denying the Holocaust or engaging in antisemitic hate speech is not illegal, except when there is an imminent threat of violence. Many other countries, particularly in Europe where the Holocaust occurred, have laws criminalizing Holocaust denial and hate speech.
This timeline lists some key events in the evolution of Holocaust denial.
1942-1944: To conceal the evidence of their annihilation of Europe's Jews, Germans and their collaborators destroy evidence of mass graves at the Belzec, Sobibor, and Treblinka killing centers, and at thousands of sites of mass shooting operations throughout German-occupied Poland, the German-occupied Soviet Union, and Serbia, including Babi Yar, in an operation code named Aktion 1005.
1943: In a speech to SS Generals at Poznan, Heinrich Himmler, Reich Leader (Reichsführer) of the SS (Schutzstaffel; Protection Squadrons), remarks that the mass murder of the European Jews will be kept secret, never to be recorded.
1955: Willis Carto founds an influential, far right group based in Washington, DC, that eventually comes to be known as the Liberty Lobby. Led by Carto until its bankruptcy in 2001, the Liberty Lobby advocates a “racially pure” United States and blames Jews for problems facing the US and the world. The Liberty Lobby begins to publish Holocaust denial literature in 1969.
1959: American clergyman Gerald L. K. Smith's antisemitic publication, Cross and the Flag, claims that six million Jews were not killed during the Holocaust but immigrated to the United States during World War II.
1964: Paul Rassinier, a French Communist who had been interned by the Nazis, publishes The Drama of European Jewry, in which he claims that gas chambers were an invention of a “Zionist establishment.”
1966-67: American historian Harry Elmer Barnes publishes articles in the Libertarian periodical Rampart Journal claiming that the Allies overstated the extent of Nazi atrocities in order to justify a war of aggression against the Axis powers.
1969: Noontide Press, a subsidiary of the Liberty Lobby, publishes a book entitled The Myth of the Six Million.
1973: Austin J. App, professor of English literature at LaSalle University in Philadelphia, publishes a pamphlet: The Six Million Swindle: Blackmailing the German People for Hard Marks with Fabricated Corpses. The pamphlet becomes a foundation for future claims by Holocaust deniers.
1976: Northwestern University engineering professor Arthur R. Butz publishes The Hoax of the Twentieth Century: The Case Against the Presumed Extermination of European Jewry. Butz was the first Holocaust denier to use the pretense of academic rigor to disguise his falsehoods. Northwestern responds by declaring Butz's statements an “embarrassment” to the university.
1977: Ernst Zündel, a German citizen living in Canada, establishes Samisdat Publishers, which issues neo-Nazi literature that includes Holocaust denial. In 1985 the Canadian government prosecuted Zündel with distributing information he knew to be false.
1977: David Irving publishes Hitler's War, arguing that Hitler neither ordered nor condoned the Nazi policy of the genocide of the European Jews. Irving distorts historical evidence and scholarly methods to lend legitimacy to his thesis.
1978: William David McCalden (also known as Lewis Brandon) and Willis Carto found the Institute for Historical Review (IHR) in California, which publishes material and sponsors conferences denying the Holocaust. The IHR masks its hateful, racist messages under the guise of valid academic inquiry.
1981: A French court convicts literature professor Robert Faurisson of inciting hatred and discrimination for calling the Holocaust a “historical lie.”
1984: In a landmark case, a Canadian court convicts public school teacher James Keegstra of “willfully promoting hatred against an identifiable group” for espousing Holocaust denial and other antisemitic views to his social studies students.
1986: On July 8, the Israeli parliament passes a law criminalizing denial of the Holocaust.
1987: California-based Bradley Smith founds the Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust. During the early 1990s, Smith's organization places full-page advertisements or editorial pieces in more than a dozen American college newspapers under the headline “The Holocaust Story: How Much is False? The Case for Open Debate.” Smith's campaign helps to blur the line between hate mongering and freedom of speech.
1987: Jean Marie Le Pen, leader of France's far right Nation Front party, suggests that gas chambers were merely a “detail” of World War II. Le Pen runs for president in France in 1988 and comes in fourth.
1987: Moroccan-Swedish writer Ahmed Rami begins broadcasting on Radio Islam, based in Sweden. The station describes the Holocaust as a Zionist/Jewish claim. Radio Islam later posts The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, Mein Kampf, and other antisemitic texts on its website.
1988: At the request of Ernst Zündel, Fred Leuchter (a self-proclaimed specialist in execution methods) travels to the site of the Auschwitz killing center. He later issues the Leuchter Report : An Engineering Report on the Alleged Execution Gas Chambers at Auschwitz, Birkenau and Majdanek, Poland, which is cited by Holocaust deniers to cast doubt on the use of gas chambers for mass murder.
1989: David Duke, a white supremacist, wins a seat in the Louisiana State Legislature. Duke sells Holocaust denial literature from his legislative office.
1990: After Illinois becomes the first American state to mandate teaching about the Holocaust in public schools, parents Ingeborg and Safet Sarich publicly protest by pulling their 13-year-old daughter out of school. The Sariches also mail 6,000 letters to public officials, scholars, journalists, and Holocaust survivors attacking the historical record as “rumors and exaggerations.”
1990: The French government enacts the Gayssot Law which declares that questioning the scale or existence of crimes against humanity (as defined in the London Charter of 1945) is a criminal offense. This act marks the first European statute explicitly outlawing denial of the Holocaust.
1990: In the course of criminal proceedings brought against Fred Leuchter by the State of Massachusetts, it is revealed that Leuchter never actually earned an engineering degree or license. Leuchter admits that he has no training in biology, toxicology, or chemistry, all of which are crucial to the claims of the 1988 Leuchter Report, which is often cited to support claims made by Holocaust deniers.
1990: A Swedish court sentences Ahmed Rami to six months in jail for “hate speech” and revokes the broadcasting license of Radio Islam for one year.
1991: The American Historical Association, the oldest professional organization of historians, issues a statement: “No serious historian questions that the Holocaust took place.”
2000: A British court declares David Irving an “active Holocaust denier.” Irving had sued Emory University historian Deborah Lipstadt for libel following the publication of her 1993 book Denying the Holocaust The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory.
2005: In a speech broadcast on live television on December 14, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad calls the Holocaust a “myth.”
2006: Iran's government sponsors a meeting of Holocaust deniers in Tehran cloaked as an academic conference called “Review of the Holocaust: Global Vision.”
2007: On January 26, the United Nations adopts a resolution condemning denial of the Holocaust. The General Assembly declares that denial is “tantamount to approval of genocide in all its forms.”
2007: The European Union approves legislation that makes Holocaust denial a crime punishable by time in jail.
2009: English-born Catholic Bishop Richard Williamson denies the existence of gas chambers and minimizes the extent of killing during the Holocaust. The Vatican eventually calls on Williamson to retract his statements.
2010: Bradley Smith places his first online Holocaust denial advertisement, which appears on the website of the University of Wisconsin's Badger Herald in February. The Internet—because of its ease of access and dissemination, seeming anonymity, and perceived authority—is now the chief conduit of Holocaust denial.
Related Articles
--------------
THAT'S MY
KING-... Catholic Christian Symbol
IRNI (LATIN: IESVS·NAZARENVS·REX·IVDAEORVM
TRANSLATES- Jesus the Nazarene, King of
the Jews)
....YOU CAN'T OUTLIVE HIM.....AND YOU CAN'T
LIVE WITHOUT HIM...... Oh Praise the Lord... Our Lord and Saviour...Jesus
Christ
Dr. S.M. Lockeridge -That's My King: Do you
know him? - 1976 sermon in Detroit
The Purpose (Get Up Weary Soldier)
CANADA: The Jewish kid in the Christmas pageant
By Bernie M. Farber, Ottawa December 23, 2012
As I gaze at the palm trees, green grass and
lush vegetation outside my in-laws’ condo in Boca Raton, I still cannot
reconcile a warm summer-like Christmas with my rich memories growing up in
Ottawa, where Christmas meant mounds of snow and icy cold temperatures.
Don’t get me wrong, I love the idea of being
able to sit on the beach, take in the sun and read the latest Ken Follett
novel, but nostalgia is a powerful seducer and memory itself a warm blanket.
I’m not sure what to think about climate
change, but I do know that as a child growing up in Ottawa in the 1950s an
’60s, snow, wind and cold seemed as inseparable at this time of the year as
potato latkes and Hannukah. And I am also drawn to the strong recollection of
being one of only a small number of Jewish families in Ottawa inescapably
caught in a Christmas spirit that enveloped us all.
While today arguments ensue about the proper
“holiday greeting,” in Ottawa, in the latter half of the 20th century it seemed
commonplace to wish everyone a “Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.” To be
sure, this had as much to do with the different patterns of immigration then
and now, but it also had to do with what I could only describe as the spirit of
the season as well.
My memories of the time are rich and deep of
those few days just before the Christmas holidays as I walked beside my father,
who often took me to school on his way to open our small family grocery store.
Despite the bitter cold, I felt warm bundled up in my wool overcoat, scarf and
that ugly cap with sheepskin flaps that covered my ears. I still recall warmly
that crunch of the snow under our heels as we walked up the Somerset Street
hill toward my elementary school.
Osgoode Street Public School, established in
1898, covered grades from kindergarten to Grade 6. It was an interesting
hodgepodge of children from many immigrant families that had settled in the
Sandy Hill area of Ottawa just after the war. They were mostly Eastern European
whose first language ranged from Ukrainian to Italian with smatterings of
German, Polish and, like mine, the odd Yiddish-speaking family. Including
myself, my younger brother Stan and the Cohen twins, we were the only Jewish
children at Osgoode Street Public School.
Christmas pageants were a regular and highly
anticipated holiday assembly. We all got to play roles from shepherds wearing
cotton beards to angels with paper wings. I still recall my parents’ sardonic
smiles when I came home in early December 1960 to announce that I would be
playing Joseph that year.
All the Jewish kids so much wanted simply to
fit in. We felt so different and Christmas, though not our holiday, seemed a
time where the usual anti-Semitic taunts we had to endure daily gave way to a
cheery “Merry Christmas.” I loved the Christmas carols, the words of which are
ingrained to this day in my mind. I can still sing a mean Joy To The World as
well as Dreidel Dreidel, Dreidel. Indeed many years later as a social worker
with the Children’s Aid Society it was the Jewish guy who led the group of
foster children in carol-singing during the regular Christmas parties.
But my most vivid memory of the time was the
Jewish-owned Freiman’s department store on downtown Rideau Street. Many decades
later it was bought by the Bay Company but in 1960 it was Ottawa’s Christmas
winter wonderland. With a miniature train that began inside the Freiman’s show
window, we were all awed as it chugged its way through Toyland towards who else
but Santa Clause himself.
I recall the great worry of that time I
departed the train and decided I too would sit on Santa’s lap. As I approached
the white bearded man, my Jewish heart pumping a mile a minute, I wondered if
an electrical bolt would be sent down from the heavens.
Turns out Santa was none other than Moishe
Gorinsky a Jewish friend of my father’s moonlighting that year as a department
store Santa.
It was a sobering experience for a
nine-year-old Jewish boy in 1960, to be sure.
Today the season is much different. Christmas
is openly shared with the many other rich faith traditions that make up Canada
in the 21st century. Kwanza, Diwali, my own Hannukah celebration, have been
woven into this time of the year, making us all feel part of the season. And
while I welcome and embrace the changes, from time to time I cannot help but
bring to mind a simpler time long ago when a young Jewish boy sat on a the lap
of a Jewish Santa while in the same year playing Joseph in his school Christmas
pageant.
Bernie M. Farber, formerly the CEO of Canadian
Jewish Congress, is a senior vice-president with Gemini Power Corporation. He
writes often on human rights and the human condition.
Israel takes in more Bnei Menashe 'lost
tribe' members The Bnei Menashe tribe is believed to have descended from the
ancient northern kingdom of Israel
25 December 2012 Last updated at 05:12 ET
Dozens of members of an Indian tribe said to
be lost descendants of ancient Israelites have emigrated to Israel after the
government lifted a visa ban.
Some 1,700 of the 7,200-strong Bnei Menashe
already arrived nearly a decade ago after a chief rabbi recognised the
community as a lost tribe in 2005.
Israel stopped issuing visas to the group two
years later but recently reversed the policy.
Some critics have questioned the authenticity
of the tribe's claims.
The community says it is one of the lost 10 tribes
of Israel who were exiled when Assyrians invaded the northern kingdom of Israel
in the 8th Century BC.
According to its oral tradition, the tribe
travelled through Persia, Afghanistan, Tibet, China and on to India, where it
eventually settled in the north-eastern states of Manipur and Mizoram.
'Never forgotten'
Around 50 people landed in the city of Tel
Aviv on Monday.
Eyewitnesses said there were emotional scenes
at Ben Gurion airport as the newcomers were greeted by relatives who had moved
to Israel during the first wave of immigration.
Several hundred more Bnei Menashe members are
due to arrive in the coming weeks, said Michael Freund, chairman of the Shavei
Israel group which helped organise the journey for the Bnei Menashe members.
"The members of this tribe have never
forgotten where they came from and we are excited to be able to help them come
back," he told AFP news agency.
But some critics say the Bnei Menashe's link
to Judaism are "historically untenable". They accuse the community of
using their status to escape poverty India.
In March 2005, Israeli Chief Rabbi Shlomo Amar
officially backed Bnei Menashe's claims after an investigation lasting several
years.
The announcement led to a wave of immigration
to the "Promised Land", where members were formally converted to
Orthodox Judaism.
The flow stopped in 2007, however, when the
government rescinded visa rights to the Bnei Menashe.
Israel's decision to reverse the policy is
expected to pave the way for all remaining members to migrate.
--------------------
The Romans in Israel
by Elizabeth McNamer
St. Luke, in his prelude to the birth of
Jesus, tells us, "In those days Caesar Augustus published a decree
ordering a census of the whole world. This first census took place while
Quirinius was governor of Syria." All through the Gospels we are aware of
a Roman presence in Israel. Just who were they, how did they get there and how
did the Jews function under Roman rule?
It all began as a family quarrel sometime in
the year 63 B.C. Two brothers from the Hasmonean dynasty, Hyrcanus and
Aristobulus, vied for the throne in Jerusalem. They were descended from the
great Maccabees, the family that had succeeded in ousting the abhorred Greeks
from Israel some hundred years before. The Maccabees had established themselves
as high priests and kings in Israel in no uncertain terms.
For a hundred years the mighty Romans had been
advancing eastward. In 67 B.C. General Pompey reached Syria and established it
as a province for Rome. Cities were built to assure Rome's eternal presence in
the area and Pompey settled for a time at least before he would assert his
rights in Rome. One day he received two messages for help from Hyrcanus and
Aristobulus. Neither one was ready to relinquish power and called on Rome to
intervene. Pompey was only too happy to come to their assistance.
What should have been settled over the weekend
turned into a 500-year nightmare. Inviting the Romans in to solve the problem
was engaging a lion to destroy a mouse. Like the man who came to dinner and
never left, the Romans considered the invitation permanent. Mighty Rome was not
to be trifled with. It took its duty seriously. When it came to the aid of a
smaller state, it formed an alliance that was irrevocable and any attempt to
negate it was regarded as a rebellion. Rome settled the dispute in favor of
Hyrcanus, but he scarcely had time to thumb his nose at his brother when he
realized that he had lost all power and that the noble Hasmonean Empire was at
an end.
It was Rome's custom to place a friendly king
on the throne of any country on their borders that they had no wish to govern.
They called them client kings. Hyrcanus was allowed to rule a small territory,
but he ruled only in name. The real power was in the hands of his minister
Antipater, a man who had proved himself a friend to the Romans, and he would
become the father of a man who would be an even greater friend: Herod the
Great. The Romans had come to Palestine and they would remain there, looking down
their long noses at the inhabitants until their Empire fell in the late fifth
century A.D.
The Roman Empire
In the year 37 B.C., the young Octavian became
Emperor of Rome with the title Augustus Caesar. He confirmed Herod, as he did
client kings in many other places, as king of the Jews. Herod owed allegiance
to Rome, but he could do anything he liked within his territory as long as
foreign policy did not get out of line. Should he fail to please the Romans he
would be immediately deposed.
Rome's empire encompassed the whole of the
known world. They had an ingenious government. The Empire was divided into
provinces and able men were sent there to govern. On arrival, a governor,
accompanied by his engineers, architects, builders and army, set about
constructing roads and cities to establish their permanent presence. Once can
see the remains of these ancient cities all over the Middle East today.
During the time of Augustus the Pax Romana was
in force. Rome was not engaged in war. But they were always prepared for it.
Roman soldiers operated all over the Empire. Nine legions were concentrated in
the East. A legion was composed of foot soldiers holding Roman citizenship.
They were professionals who had signed up for 25 years. A legion consisted of ten
cohorts divided into six "centuries" of 100 men each. Each century
was commanded by a centurion. There were one hundred cavalry attached to each
legion, so that there were somewhat over six thousand men in all. They were
armed with heavy javelins and short thrusting swords as well as a small dagger.
They wore helmets and mail shirts made of small iron rings and they carried
large curved wooden shields.
In addition to the legions, auxiliary forces
were drawn from the province. Those serving in these forces did not have Roman
citizenship. They were organized into cohorts like the legions and could be
called upon by the governors for help at any time. While a century of soldiers
was present at Capernaum (Jesus cured the centurion's son), it is now thought that
these were not Romans but were part of the army of Herod Antipas. Capernaum was
on the border of his territory and taxes were collected here, particularly from
the fishermen. At the time of Jesus Roman soldiers would have been found only
around Caesarea Maratima where the Roman procurator lived. They would have been
called into use when the great festivals were being celebrated in Jerusalem to
prevent uprisings, or they would be needed in the execution of criminals by
crucifixion.
Living under Roman rule had some advantages.
Generally they allowed freedom of religion (unlike the Greeks had done) and did
not interfere with the religious practices of the people they governed. The
governors of provinces built temples to their own gods. where sacrifices were
conducted daily. But it was the Roman method of taxation that most stung.
Provinces had to pay taxes. An amount was estimated and the country split up
into tax districts. As Rome had no civil service, taxes were collected by
private syndicates who made a large profit by overcollecting. Taxes on goods
were very high. Not surprisingly, tax collectors were despised.
Herod the Great
During the time of Herod the Great there were
probably no Roman soldiers to be found in Israel. He had his own private army,
and auxiliary units could always be called in if there was trouble. Like the
Romans, Herod set out on a great building program. Among the towns he erected
was Caesarea Maratima on the coast of the Mediterranean. This splendid town had
a theater, an amphitheater, a stadium, a chariot-racing arena, public baths, a
temple to Augustus, a splendid palace for himself and a false harbor so that he
could import his marble and wine and all the commodities needed by a king. No
expense was spared in the building of the city and he invited the emperor
Augustus to the opening.
But Herod never lived there. He died in 4 B.C.
before it was entirely completed and his territory was divided among his sons,
who received the title tetrarch rather than king. Archelaus got Judea; Herod
Antipas, Samaria and Galilee; Philip Herod, Trachonitis, Gaulanitis and
Batanea.
Judea, which contained the holy city of
Jerusalem, was going to be the most difficult to govern. At Passover the year
after Herod died, thousands of pilgrims came pouring into the temple. Archelaus
sent his troops (he had 3,000 of them) to control the crowd, but the crowd
turned on the soldiers and stoned them to death. Some 3,000 people ended up
being killed in the ensuing conflict. The governor of Syria took it upon
himself to place a legion at Jerusalem to keep the peace. But at Pentecost more
crowds came pouring in and climbed on the temple porticoes to pelt the Roman
soldiers. The whole country was soon up in arms and the governor of Syria
returned with more legions. Two thousand of the rebels were captured and
crucified.
Enter the Procurators
Archelaus proved to be such an inept and cruel
ruler that in A.D. 6 the people of Judea asked that a Roman procurator be
appointed in his place under the watchful eye of the governor of Syria
(Quirinius). The Syrian governor ordered a census of all property in order to
estimate taxes and to sell off the estate of Archelaus. This was bitterly
resented by the Jews.
Since the high priest had failed to convince
the Jews that a census should be taken, he was replaced by a new high priest,
Annas, who would keep the position until A.D. 15. Archelaus's troops were taken
over by the Romans and turned into auxiliary units. The proconsul was given
supreme power. He had total authority over the region. He could imprison, flog
or execute as he saw fit. He set up his government at Caesarea Maratima and
moved into Herod's palace.
The first three procurators governed for only
a year each. The next, Valerian Gratus, did a 17-year stint. Then, in A.D. 26,
Emperor Tiberius appointed as procurator of Judea a man called Pontius Pilate.
Pontius Pilate is described as greedy,
vindictive and cruel by historians of the time. He had nothing but contempt for
Jewish customs. He was deliberately provocative. The soldiers had been
forbidden to carry their standards into Jerusalem because the images of the
emperor would offend the Jews. Pilate ordered his soldiers to take in the
standards under cover of night. A mob descended on Caesarea and besieged him
for five days. He removed the standards. A new aqueduct was needed to bring
water into Jerusalem. Pilate paid for the building of an aqueduct with Temple
taxes. This again infuriated the Jews. Afraid of a riot, Pilate had some of his
soldiers dress like Jews, mingle with the people and, at the first sign of
trouble, kill the potential troublemakers.
It was customary for the proconsul to go to
Jerusalem for the main feasts. Thus for Passover in the year 30, we find Pilate
in Jerusalem.
The Zealots
Gamla is poised on a rocky ridge protected on
each side by sweeping valleys in the Galilean hills. Here the Zealot movement
had been founded by Judas the Galilean and a Pharisee named Zadduk in A.D. 6,
at the time of the census by Quirinius.
They preached that God alone was the ruler of
Israel and that no taxes should be paid. Judas' family paid a higher price in
other ways. His sons Jacob and Simeon were crucified in 46. His grandson
Menachem was murdered in Jerusalem in 66. Another grandson escaped to Masada
and committed suicide in 73.
In A.D. 66 a revolt against Roman rule was
started in Galilee. The Romans sent in their greatest general Vespasian to deal
with the situation. He did it with ruthlessness and efficiency. Some 5,000
zealots committed suicide by jumping off the Gamla cliff as the Roman army
approached.
Most of the towns that we associate with the
ministry of Jesus were destroyed—Nazareth, Capernaum, Chorazim, Bethsaida.
Vespasian was so successful that his soldiers
declared him emperor and he returned to Rome, leaving his son Titus in charge.
Titus destroyed Jerusalem. Whether he intended
to destroy the Temple is often questioned. It was one of the most magnificent
buildings in the world. Some say it caught fire by mistake. But destroyed it
was.
Some of the Zealots escaped to Masada where
they stayed for nine months before killing each other rather than fall prey to
the Romans.
We know a great deal about this period because
of the writings of Josephus. He was an Israelite general in the army that
fought against Rome. He tells us that had he not been thrown from his horse and
sprained his wrist during one of the battles and taken for medical attention to
Capernaum, the history of the world would have been changed.
Be that as it may, in the long run he turned
traitor and joined the Romans. It is said that he sat with Titus watching the
destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem. He was taken by Titus to Rome,
ensconced in an apartment and told to write a history of the Jewish wars. He also
wrote a history of the Jews and his own life.
Elizabeth McNamer, one of the general editors
of Scripture from Scratch and a frequent contributor, has a Ph.D. in adult
education and religious studies from Montana State University and an M.A. in
religious studies from Gonzaga University. She teaches at Rocky Mountain
College.
Next: The Canticles in Luke's Gospel (by
Daniel W. Casey)
-------------
Jesus
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jesus (pron.: /'d?i?z?s/; Greek: ??s???
Iesous; 7–2 BC/BCE to 30–36 AD/CE), also referred to as Jesus of Nazareth, is
the central figure of Christianity, whom a majority of Christian denominations
believe to be the Son of God.[11]
Virtually all scholars of antiquity agree that
Jesus existed.[12][13][14][15][16][17] Most scholars agree that Jesus was a
Jewish teacher from Galilee in Roman Judaea, was baptized by John the Baptist,
and was crucified in Jerusalem on the orders of the Roman Prefect, Pontius
Pilate.[8][18][15] However, the quest for the historical Jesus has produced
little agreement on the historicity of gospel narratives and their theological
assertions of his divinity.[19][20][21][22] Scholars have offered various
portraits of Jesus, which at times share a number of overlapping attributes,
such as the leader of an apocalyptic movement, Messiah, a charismatic healer, a
sage and philosopher, or a social reformer who preached of the "Kingdom of
God" as a means for personal and egalitarian social
transformation.[23][24][25][26] Scholars have correlated the New Testament
accounts with non-Christian historical records to arrive at an estimated
chronology of Jesus' life.[3][5][27][28]
Christians hold Jesus to be the awaited
Messiah of the Old Testament and refer to him as Jesus Christ or simply as
Christ,[29][30] a name that is also used secularly. Most Christians believe
that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of a virgin, performed
miracles, founded the Church, died sacrificially by crucifixion to achieve
atonement, rose from the dead, and ascended into heaven, from which he will
return.[31] The majority of Christians worship Jesus as the incarnation of God
the Son, and the Second Person of the Holy Trinity.[32] A few Christian groups
reject Trinitarianism, wholly or partly, as non-scriptural.[32][33]
In Islam, Jesus (commonly transliterated as
Isa) is considered one of God's important prophets.[34][35] In Islam, Jesus is
a bringer of scripture, and the product of a virgin birth, but not the victim
of crucifixion. Judaism rejects the belief that Jesus was the awaited Messiah,
arguing that he did not fulfill the Messianic prophecies in the Tanakh.[36]
Bahá'í scripture almost never refers to Jesus as the Messiah, but calls him a
Manifestation of God.[37]
--------------------------------
HISTORY
of
Israel & "Palestine"
Israel
today + Jordan today = "Pal estine" Before 1923
Take
a close look at this PRESENT DAY MAP of the Middle East in which you can see
that 22 Arab and/or Muslim [Iran is not considered Arab] nations completely
engulf Israel. If someone can explain to me how "expansionist Israel"
has "taken over" the Middle East, please email me! The Arab countries
occupy 640 times the land mass as does Israel and outnumber the Jews of Israel
by nearly fifty to one. So much for Arab propaganda!
Now
notice the TOTAL area of Israel and
Jordan. This was referred to
as "Palestine" and mandated
under British administration following World War I (see next map below). How
convenient that today's Arab propagandists forget that land east of the Jordan
River was also part of "Palestine" and is, in fact, the
Arab-Palestinian State!
From
1517-1917 Turkey's Ottoman Empire controlled a vast Arab empire, a portion of
which is today Lebanon, Syria, and Palestine.
During World War I (1914-1918), Turkey supported Germany. When Germany
was defeated, so were the Turks. In 1916 control of the southern portion of
their Ottoman Empire was "mandated" to France and Britain under the
Sykes-Picot Agreement, which divided the Arab region into zones of influence.
Lebanon and Syria were assigned (mandated) to France... and
"Palestine" (today's Jordan, Israel and "West Bank") was
mandated to Great Britain.
Because no other peoples had ever established a national homeland in
"Palestine" since the Jews had done it 2,000 years before, the
British "looked favorably" upon the creation of a Jewish National
Homeland throughout ALL of Palestine. The Jews had already begun mass
immigration into Palestine in the 1880's in an effort to rid the land of swamps
and malaria and prepare for the rebirth of Israel. This Jewish effort to
revitalize the land attracted an equally large immigration of Arabs from
neighboring areas who were drawn by employment opportunities and healthier
living conditions. There was never any attempt to "rid" the area of
what few indigenous Arabs there were or those Arab masses that immigrated into
this area along with the Jews!
In 1923, the British divided the
"Palestine" portion of the Ottoman Empire into two administrative
districts. Jews would be permitted only
west of the Jordan river. In effect, the
British had "chopped off" 75% of the originally proposed Jewish
Palestinian homeland to form an Arab Palestinian nation called Trans-Jordan
(meaning "across the Jordan River"). This territory east of the
Jordan River was given to Emir Abdullah (from Hejaz, now Saudi Arabia) who was
not even an Arab-"Palestinian!" This portion of Palestine was renamed
Trans-Jordan. Trans-Jordan would again be renamed "Jordan" in 1946.
In other words, the eastern 3/4 of Palestine would be renamed TWICE, in effect,
erasing all connection to the name "Palestine!" However, the bottom
line is that the Palestinian Arabs had THEIR "Arab Palestinian"
homeland. The remaining 25% of Palestine (now WEST of the Jordan River) was to
be the Jewish Palestinian homeland.
However, sharing was not part of the Arab psychological makeup then nor
now.
Encouraged and incited by growing Arab nationalism throughout the Middle
East, the Arabs of that small remaining Palestinian territory west of the
Jordan River launched never-ending murderous attacks upon the Jewish
Palestinians in an effort to drive them out.
Most terrifying were the Hebron massacres of 1929 and later during the
1936-39 "Arab Revolt." The British at first tried to maintain order
but soon (due to the large oil deposits being discovered throughout the Arab
Middle East) turned a blind eye. It became painfully clear to the Palestinian
Jews that they must fight the Arabs AND drive out the British.
The
Palestinian Jews were forced to form an organized defense against the Arabs
Palestinians.... thus was formed the Hagana, the beginnings of the Israeli
Defense Forces [IDF]. There was also a Jewish underground called the Irgun led
by Menachem Begin (who later became Prime Minister of Israel). Besides fighting
the Arabs, the Irgun was instrumental in driving out the pro-Arab British. Finally in 1947 the British had enough and
turned the Palestine matter over to the United Nations.
The
1947 U.N. Resolution 181 partition plan was to divide the remaining 25% of
Palestine into a Jewish Palestinian State and a SECOND Arab Palestinian State
(Trans-Jordan being the first) based upon population concentrations. The Jewish Palestinians accepted... the Arab
Palestinians rejected. The Arabs still wanted ALL of Palestine... both east AND
west of the Jordan River.
Our
Palestinian Cousins started the '48 war, and in so doing released the warlike
appetites of a nation of survivors, a Jewish people with no place to run, who
had repressed their rage for millennia, and had now earned full title to it!
On
May 14, 1948 the "Palestinian Jews" finally declared their own State
of Israel and became "Israelis." On the next day, seven neighboring
Arab armies... Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Yemen...
invaded Israel. Most of the Arabs living within the boundaries of the newly
declared "ISRAEL" were encouraged to leave by the invading Arab
armies to facilitate the slaughter of the Jews and were promised to be given
all Jewish property after the victorious Arab armies won the war. The truth is
that 70% of the Arab Palestinians who left in 1948 – perhaps 300,000 to 400,000
of them – never saw an Israeli soldier! They did not flee because they feared
Jewish thugs, but because of a rational and reasonable calculus: the Jews will
be exterminated; we will get out of the way while that messy and dangerous
business goes forward, and we will return afterwards to reclaim our homes, and
to inherit those nice Jewish properties as well. They guessed wrong; and the
Arab Palestinians are still tortured by the residual shame of their flight.
Their shame is so great because in their eyes running from Jews was like
running from women. So much for the blatant lie about Jews throwing out all the
[Palestinian] Arabs!
The remaining 30% either (1) saw for
themselves that these Jews would fight and die for their new nation and decided
to pack up and leave or (2) were driven off the land as a normal consequence of
war.
When the 19 month war ended, Israel
survived despite a 1% loss of its entire
population! Those Arabs who did not flee became today's Israeli-Arab citizens.
Those who fled became the seeds of the first wave of "Palestinian Arab
refugees."
The Arab propagandists and apologists almost
never mentioned that in 1948, Arab armies launched a war against a one-day-old
Israel. Instead he focused on the main consequence of that war: the creation of
Arab refugees, stating that Israel "war of genocide" expelled 800,000
of them. This not only disagrees with UN estimates of a bit over 400,000
refugees but also ignores the fact that most of the Arabs/Palestinians were
encouraged to leave by the Arab World itself!
The end result of the 1948-49 Israeli War of
Independence was the creation of a Jewish State slightly larger than that which
was proposed by the 1947 United Nations Resolution 181. What remained of that
almost-created second Arab Palestinian
State was gobbled up by (1) Egypt (occupying the Gaza Strip) and by (2)
Trans-Jordan (occupying Judea-Samaria (a.k.a. the "West Bank" of the
Jordan River) and Jerusalem. In the next year (1950) Trans-Jordan formally
merged this West Bank territory into itself and granted all those
"Palestinian" Arabs living there Jordanian citizenship. Since Trans-Jordan was then no longer
confined to one side of the Jordan
River, it renamed itself simply "Jordan." In the final analysis, the Arabs of Palestine
ended up with nearly 85% of the original territory of Palestine... called Jordan
but in reality their ARAB "Palestinian state! But that was still not 100%
and thus the conflict between Arab and Jew for "Palestine" would
continue through four more wars and continuous Arab terrorist attacks upon the Israeli citizenry. It
continues to this very day.
From
1949-67 when all of Judea-Samaria [West Bank & Jerusalem] and Gaza ... were
100% under Arab [Jordanian & Egyptian] control, no effort was EVER made to
create a second Palestinian State for the Arabs living there. Surely you do not expect Israel to now
provide these same Arabs with their own country when their fellow Arabs failed
to do so! And isn't it curious how
Arafat and his PLO (formed in 1964) discovered
their "ancient" identity and a need for
"self-determination" and "human dignity" on this very same
West Bank ONLY AFTER Israel regained this territory (three years later in 1967)
following Jordan's attempt attempt to destroy Israel! Why was no request ever made upon King
Hussein of Jordan by the Arabs living on the West Bank when he occupied
it? Is it logical that the PLO was
formed in 1964 to regain the lands they would lose three years later in
1967? This sort of logic makes sense
only to those who who have not learned that the PLO was formed to DESTROY
Israel. And that is STILL their goal! A cosmetic name change from PLO
(Palestine Liberation Organization) to PA (Palestinian Authority) does not
change the stripes on THIS tiger!
Throughout much of May 1967, the Egyptian, Jordanian and Syrian armies mobilized along Israel's narrow and
seemingly indefensible borders in preparation for a massive invasion to
eliminate the State of Israel. The battle cry heard throughout the Arab world
was then, as it continues to be... "Slaughter the Jews" and
"Throw the Jews into the Sea!" But the Jews of Israel, remembering
2,000 years of being butchered, gassed,
burned and skinned (eg. The Crusades, The Spanish Inquisition, the Arab
rampages of early Palestine and particularly the Holocaust), planned and executed a perfect pre-emptive
strike against Egypt. Within two hours the Egyptian Air Force did not exist...
most of its planes destroyed while still on the runways! Unaware that the Egyptians had no more air
force, King Hussein of Jordan, launched
his attack from the his West Bank into Israel's belly while Syrian troops
prepared to descend down the Golan Heights high ground into northern
Israel.
Now for some facts about
"occupation." Firstly, the Egyptians, Jordanians and Syrians lost
Gaza, the West Bank and Golan Heights (respectively) by participating in a
failed attempt at genocide against the Children of Israel. Had Israel lost this
1967 defensive war, the Arab-Palestinians and their Arab allies would have
raped, butchered or driven out every Israeli they could get their hands on and
gobbled up all of Israel. Now, 35+ years later and despite the fact that Israel
won a war BROUGHT UPON THEM, the Israelis are still willing to allow the
Arab-Palestinians to have a state on much of the West Bank and Gaza if only
they will stop sending their suicide/homicide bombers into the heart of Israel!
(Talk about misplaced compassion!)
From 1948 to 1967, Egypt ruled Gaza, Syria
ruled the Golan Heights, while Jordan ruled the West Bank. They could have set
up independent Arab-Palestinian states in any or all of those territories, but
they didn't even consider it. Instead, in 1967 they used the Golan Heights,
Gaza and the West bank to launch a war that was unambiguously aimed at
destroying Israel, which is how Israel came into possession of those
territories in the first place.
After ONLY six days of air, sea and hand-to-hand ground warfare, Israel
defeated all three Arab armies along three separate fronts, capturing the
entire Sinai Desert from Egypt, the 37mile x 12mile Syrian Golan Heights and
the so-called "West Bank" (including East Jerusalem and its Old City)
from Jordan. The God of Israel was surely watching over His children! Most importantly was the return to Israel of
its holy 3,000 year old capital city of Jerusalem along the western edge of the
West Bank... the same Jerusalem from which all Jews had been denied access for
the 19 years (1948-1967) following Jordan's seizure and control over it
following the first Arab-Israeli War of 1948-9.
Unfortunately, the world saw things differently and considered Israel an
"occupier" (rather than a "capturer") of this disputed
"West Bank" and the Gaza Strip along with the 850,000 Palestinian
Arabs living there. These Arabs would refer to themselves as "refugees"
and joined the masses of refugees from the first Arab-Israeli war of 1948-9.
Once again Israel was forced to fight a battle for survival and, sadly, once
again Palestinian [in reality, largely Egyptian, Jordanian and Syrian] Arabs
becoming refugees by their own actions, the actions of their leaders and from
the actions of fellow Arabs from neighboring states!
ISRAEL SCREWS UP TOO!
Israel was responsible for bringing about some of its own problems. The
Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza Strip were packed and ready to leave following
their 1967 defeat. Suddenly the
victorious one-eyed IDF General Moshe Dayan persuaded them to stay. This
singular act stunned no one more than the Arab enemy himself who could not
believe such an incredible manifestation of Jewish madness! After all, the Arabs knew what THEY would
have done to the Jews if they had won!
Dayan's plan was to educate them, offer them modern medical treatment,
provide them with employment both in the West Bank, Gaza AND inside Israel
Proper itself ... living amongst each other in hopes of building bridges to the
Arab world. Israel is now paying dearly
for this typically naive "Leftist" gesture. That "bridge" led to two Intifadas
and world-wide Arab-Palestinian terrorism.
From a frightened and defeated enemy, these "Palestinian"
Arabs under Israel's jurisdiction turned into a confident, hateful and
dangerous enemy now on their way toward forming a terrorist state determined to
destroy Israel!
Note: When people say Jordan (first called
Trans-Jordan) is an Arab-"Palestinian" State, they are correct!
Jordan accounts for 3/4 of Palestine's original land mass. Though they may call
themselves "Jordanians," they are culturally, ethnically,
historically and religiously no different than the Arab-"Palestinians"
on the "West Bank." Even the flag of Jordan and the flag of the
proposed 2nd Arab-Palestinian state on the West Bank / Gaza look almost
identical. So, if the Arab-Palestinians and Jordanians think of themselves as
one and the same, why should WE fall for the lie that the Arab Palestinians
west of the Jordan River are any different from the Jordanian Arabs on its
eastern shore?
Jordanian Flag
Proposed Palestinian Flag
Usually when one side starts a war and loses both the war AND some
territory, no one on the planet would expect the winner to give back anything!
This not only sounds preposterous, it IS preposterous! But the Jews (I hate to admit) had such an
insane obsession of wanting the world to love them that they were willing to
give back the entire Sinai Desert (oil fields, air bases and endless miles of
security buffer) to Egypt for a piece of paper.
Thus, in 1982 Egypt regained their Sinai and Israel lost a massive
buffer against any future Egyptian aggression!
Thus far, Egypt has not aggressed against Israel militarily; however,
the basest, anti-Semitic bile to come out of Egypt is not unlike the worse of
Nazi anti-Jewish propaganda! This 1982 Camp David Peace Accord has to be the
coldest peace deal in history!
Israel still occupies Syria's Golan Heights which, prior to the 1967
war, had been by Syria used solely for terrorist incursions into and artillery
bombardment upon Israel's northeastern settlements. The Golan should never be given back to
Israel's most vicious enemy! And of
course, Israel still "occupies" the West Bank with its ONE MILLION TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND and Gaza
with its EIGHT HUNDRED THOUSAND "Palestinian" Arabs.
Had Israel done to these Arabs what the Arabs would have done to the
Jews had THEY won, she would have expelled these hostile Arabs and made it officially part of a
Greater Israel! But by remaining an
"occupier," Israel set herself up for a campaign of vicious
propaganda, the scope and intensity of which the world has never before seen!
More on "Palestinian Nationalism
and the
Real War Against Israel...
The Middle East war is not now and never was a
conflict between Israelis/Jews on the one hand and Palestinians on the other.
In fact, the Arab-"Palestinians", while currently the perpetrators of
most of the anti-Jewish atrocities, were never a very important part of the
conflict. In fact, before about 1970, virtually no one in the world considered
the Middle East conflict to be one between Israelis and Palestinians.
The term "Palestinian" itself had
referred to Israeli Jews back in the 1940s, and had been slowly deconstructed
and redefined to refer to the Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza. The Middle East
Conflict was always a war by Arabs against Jews, not a conflict between
Israelis and "Palestinians." The war was repackaged as a conflict
between Jews and Palestinians as a public relations gimmick by the Arab fascist
regimes. These regimes had never had any interest in "Palestinians,"
in creating a "Palestinian" state, or in "Palestinian nationalism"
before 1967. That is because Palestinian nationalism did not and DOES NOT
exist. The Palestinians were a regional group of Arabs having virtually no
cultural nor national distinctive traits separating them from Syrians,
Lebanese, and Jordanians. They are all basically Arabs!.
The bulk of what are called "Palestinian
Arabs" are members of families who migrated into the Land of Israel
beginning in the late 19th century. Palestinian nationalism is a mislabeling of
Arab nationalism. Arab nationalism exists, although it is closely bound up with
Islamic nationalism and even Islamism. Palestinian nationalism, however, is a
phantom. It is nothing more than genocidal hatred of Jews!
The Arab assaults and aggressions against
Israel in 1948, 1956, 1967, 1968, and 1973 had nothing to do with Palestinians.
The Palestinian terror campaign would itself be easy to suppress today and
eradicate if the Middle East conflict were really a Palestinian-Israeli
conflict. Israel would simply obliterate the terrorists and expel their
supporters to Syria and Lebanon. The Middle East war continues because it is
really an Arab-Israeli war, not an Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It is also in
large part a war between barbarism and civilization. In many ways an Islamic
religious jihad against the Jews.
---------
SWITZERLAND'S HATE OF JEWS...
The Red Cross should stick to helping
people in need, not waste resources in bashing Israel
THE ICRC (SWISS... INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE OF
THE RED CROSS).... AND THEIR WAR AGAINST ISRAEL...
For nearly four decades many in the
international community have insisted that Jews are forbidden to live in Judea,
Samaria and Gaza (Yesha), 'eastern Jerusalem,' and the Golan - areas conquered
by Israel in 1967. Leading this fight was and is a private Swiss organization,
the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).
The ICRC was the first international
organization to charge that "the presence of Israeli settlements in the
occupied territories is contrary to the Geneva Convention," and therefore
"unlawful."
"Any measure designed to expand or
consolidate settlements is also illegal. Confiscation of land to build or
expand settlements is similarly prohibited." (ICRC, 2009)
And the world listens, because the ICRC isn't
just another NGO; it is the official recognized authority on the Fourth Geneva
Convention (GC IV). Its decisions, therefore, were and are crucial in
determining international law and vilifying Israel. Every judicial condemnation
of Israel cites the GC and follows ICRC's interpretation.
This explains why the international community
and courts have accepted ICRC's decisions that "Israeli (Jewish)
settlements violate international law" without question.
Based on The Hague Convention, GC IV was drawn
up after WWII to protect innocent civilians and restrict brutal occupations.
Unilaterally, the ICRC turned it into a weapon to delegitimize and demonize
Israel. Meeting secretly in the early 1970's in Geneva, the ICRC determined
that Israel was in violation of the GC IV. That's been "the law" ever
since.
And there's no appeal, because all decisions
and protocols of the ICRC are closed, even the identities of the people
involved are secret. Without transparency or due process, ICRC rulings became
"international law." Their condemnations of Israel provide the sole
basis for accusing Israel of "illegal occupation" of all territory
conquered in 1967.
It's a legal fraud.
Article 49 of GC IV says: "The Occupying
Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into
the territory it occupies."
According to the ICRC, this forbids Jews from
living in Judea, Samaria, Golan and eastern Jerusalem - areas conquered by
Israel in 1967 - even though they moved there voluntarily, and prohibits any
form of government assistance to them, including roads, utilities, schools and
clinics.
The ICRC's position contradicts all written
agreements which confirm the right of Jews to live in their ancestral homeland
- League of Nations and British Mandate - including the Oslo Accords.
Article 49 obviously refers to the territory
of another country, or sovereign power; Judea, Samaria and Gaza don't fit this
definition. These areas were illegally occupied by Jordan and Egypt between
1948 and 1967; the ICRC, of course, differs, but has never satisfactorily
answered the question to which State this territory belongs.
Holding these territories in limbo for a
future Palestinian state, which may never come to fruition, whose borders are
undefined and whose intentions are openly hostile is absurd. Such ICRC
antagonism to Israel, however, is pervasive.
During WW II the ICRC visited concentration
camps and gave the Nazis a pass. After the war, they provided false passports
to escaping Nazi war criminals.
Their website demonstrates their humanitarian
efforts around the world, but when it comes to the Middle East, their story is
one-sided. During two decades of constant terrorist attacks against Israeli
civilians, the ICRC said nothing. They have written several stories about the
suffering of "Palestinians" in Gaza and Lebanon as a result of
Israeli actions, without mentioning terrorist attacks that prompted a response.
The ICRC condemned IDF actions to stop
terrorism in Jenin, Lebanon and Gaza as "massacres." They have
consistently condemned Israel for 'violations of Palestinian civil and human
rights,' and accused Israel of "war crimes." Sometimes, when these
lies were exposed, the ICRC has recanted - but not often and never with full
disclosure.
Because the ICRC lacks transparency, there's
no way to find out how and why they made their decisions, or who made them. If
they have nothing to hide, why the secrecy?
The Red Cross should stick to helping people
in need, not waste resources in bashing Israel.
and heeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeee's their
website:
... OMG!!!!!
By the by... hasn't Switzerland been taken to
task for their actions against the Jews... the war where over 6 MILLION JEWS
WERE MURDERED... along with Catholics, Gypsies and persons because of race,
colour, creed and sexual orientation.... that war? No more hiding.... let's
" get r done!"
OH Bethlehem what have they done to you?
- David Rushton (Bio and Archives) Monday, December 24, 2012
I have been privileged to visit Bethlehem more
than 40 times out of more than 60 total visits to Israel. The first time was in
1964. Now it is sadly listed among the places, like London (my hometown) and
Cairo that I never will visit again. In 1995 the birthplace of the Prince of
Peace was turned over to the “Palestinian Authority” under the terms of the
Oslo Peace Accord.
At the time of my first visit to Bethlehem it
was under occupation by the Jordanian army as was most of Jerusalem. There was
a “Berlin Wall” of barbed wire and sentry towers between what the United
Nations defined as Israel and the part occupied by Jordan. One needed a
passport and special visas to go from one side to the other.
Then came the Six Day War when Israel was
attacked by Arab armies and fought back taking back much of the land of Judea
and Samaria, including Bethlehem which had been deeded to it by God and
recorded in the Bible.
Life was good in Israel after the Six Day War.
During the ‘70s and ‘80s, I had many Jewish, Muslim, and Christian friends in
Jerusalem. Most of my friends were Arabs. The Muslims were not militant in
those days and on many evenings six or eight of us would pile into a car and
drive the ten minutes to Bethlehem to eat in one of the cafes around manger
square or drink coffee on the main street. There we were joined by other Muslim
or Christian Arab friends for a night of friendly conversation.
One by one my Muslim friends disappeared under
threats by militant Muslims that they must not consort with the enemy. Soon
there were none of them left.
Most of my friends in Bethlehem were Christian
Arab businessmen, including the Christian Mayor of the town. But after 1995
when the Israeli army pulled back to a place between Jerusalem and Bethlehem,
my Christian Arab friends told of threats and boycotts by the Muslims. Each
time I visited the town more Christian families had left to find new homes in
the United States, Canada, Europe, and South America. When we visited in 2000
we had lunch in a small restaurant that was famous for its good Middle Eastern
food. We arrived early and as we sat in the center of the room we noticed
groups of men in olive green uniforms coming in and taking up tables around us.
Each carried a rifle and laid it on the floor beside their table. A big screen
television played film of Arafat and Fatah men in training accompanied by
military music. A local man told us we were in the meeting place of Arafat’s
army. The food was still good, but we finished quickly and left.
For 3,000 years Bethlehem has been a Jewish
town and still is because God deeded it to His People Israel, and specifically
to the tribe of Judah. There are no Jews and few Christians left in Bethlehem
today because they have been forced out.
Over the centuries Bethlehem was invaded and
ruled by Samaritans, Byzantines, Persians, Romans, Crusaders, Egyptians, Mamluks,
Syrians, Turks and British. All of those great empires have fallen into the
garbage dump of history.
Bethlehem is situated in the hills of Judea
about 9 kilometers (6 miles) from Jerusalem. It is first mentioned in Genesis
35:16 as the place near where Jacob’s wife Rachel died.
“So Rachel died, and she was buried on the way
to Ephrath, that is, Bethlehem, and Jacob set up a pillar upon her grave; it is
the pillar of Rachel’s tomb, which is there to this day.” (Gen 35:19-20)
Bethlehem was the meeting place of Ruth and
Boaz. David was born here and was anointed King of Israel here by the prophet
Samuel in Bethlehem (1 Samuel 16:4-13). Could there ever be any doubt that this
is part of the Land of Israel?
According to THE TIMES OF ISRAEL
(timesofIsrael.com) Archeologist Eli Shukron, while digging in Jerusalem this
year, recovered a pottery shard that was part of a seal mentioning the city of
Bethlehem. As far as is known this is the oldest archeological proof that
Bethlehem existed as a city of Israel approximately 2,700 years ago. This was
at the time of the First Temple in Jerusalem. And this, of course, also proves,
as if any more proof is needed, that Jerusalem was the capital of Israel more
than 2,700 years ago. We know from the Bible that it was the capital and that
Bethlehem existed as Jewish town even before that.
The very name of the city is Jewish. In Hebrew
the name Bethlehem means “House of Bread” because of the wheat fields that
surround it.
The Jewish town of Bethlehem is mentioned
again in (Micah 5:2) where it is prophesied as the birthplace of the Messiah.
1st Samuel 17:12 calls it Bethlehem-Judah (or Bethlehem of the Tribe of Judah).
And the New Testament calls Bethlehem “the city of David” (Luke 2:4).
Joseph and his wife travelled to Bethlehem
while she was pregnant because the Roman authorities decreed that every family
should travel to the land of the birth of the head of the household. Joseph
then, as a descendant of King David, had to travel to Bethlehem, the City of
David.
Bethlehem, city of David and part of the tribe
of Judah, was the birthplace of the Messiah.
It is not mentioned in the Koran or other
Muslim books because they know nothing about it.
CHRISTMAS CELEBRATIONS IN BETHLEHEM
There are three dates for Christmas in Bethlehem
each year. The Roman Catholic and Protestant groups revere Dec. 25th as the day
of Nativity. Greek, Coptic (Egyptian Orthodox) and Syrian Orthodox celebrate
January 6th. Armenian Orthodox Christians celebrate on January 19th. Of course
anyone who studies the Bible and History knows that Jesus was not born anywhere
near December 25th or any time in January but more likely at the time of the
Biblical Feast of Succot (Tabernacles). Certainly the Roman authorities would
not have demanded that families travel to far away parts of the country in
December or January when it is very cold and often accompanied by snow.
WHAT MUSLIMS BELIEVE ABOUT JESUS
Muslims say they believe in Jesus. Yes they
do. They believe he was the last in a line of great prophets and was sent to
usher in the final and most important prophet, Mohammed, who would bring the
whole world to worship the moon god.
The town of Bethlehem may have been spoiled;
God’s Holy Temple may have been destroyed and paved over as a foundation for
the Mosque of Omar, but the Spirit and the Dream live on in the hearts of those
who love and stand for the God of the Bible and His Messiah.
May the Spirit of Bethlehem live on in our
hearts. Not only on December 25th, but all year long.
David Rushton was born in London where his
parents were staunch conservatives. He immigrated to the United States in the
sixties and formed a patriotic organization advocating conservative principles
which include rallies and marches. He had his own radio talk show for many
years and was also a guest on many radio and Television talk shows.
In the last few years David wrote several
books about the dangers of radical Islam and spoke on this subject in some of
the largest Conservative Churches in the United States.
He now resides with his wife Marcia in Costa
Rica.
-----------------------------
Jewish Canadians- Canada Encyclopedia
Unlike most immigrants to Canada, Jews did
not come from a place where they were the majority cultural group. Jews were
internationally dispersed at the time of the ancient Roman Empire and after
unsuccessful revolts against it lost their sovereignty in their ancient
homeland.
Unlike most immigrants to Canada, Jews did
not come from a place where they were the majority cultural group. Jews were
internationally dispersed at the time of the ancient Roman Empire and after
unsuccessful revolts against it lost their sovereignty in their ancient
homeland. Subsequently Jews lived, sometimes for many centuries, as minorities
in the Middle East, North Africa and Europe.
Early Settlement
Jews in western Europe participated in the
opening up of the Americas to European settlement, but were legally barred from
residence in New France, where immigration was restricted to Catholics. Jews
settled in the British colonies to the south and after the incorporation of New
France into the British Empire began also to settle in Lower Canada.
By 1768, the number of Jews in Montréal had grown to the point where they
decided to establish Canada's first synagogue,
Shearith Israel. By the late 18th century Jews had also settled in Québec City
and other parts of Lower Canada. The Hart family were prominent in the area of
Trois-Rivières; Ezekiel Hart was elected to the legislature of Lower Canada in
1807 but was denied his seat on the basis of his religion. Jews participated in
the settlement of Upper Canada,
establishing the first synagogue in Toronto (later Holy Blossom Temple) in
1856.
The 1871 census, the first after Confederation,
counted 1115 Jews in Canada - 409 in Montréal, 157 in Toronto, 131 in Hamilton
and smaller numbers in Québec City, Saint John, London, Kingston and Brantford.
A community of over a hundred was also settled in British Columbia when it
joined Confederation. British Columbia's first delegation to the House of
Commons included Henry Nathan, the first Jewish Canadian MP.
Mass Migration
At the end of the 19th century, 80% of the
world's 10 million Jews lived in the Russian, Austro-Hungarian and German
empires. The possibility of better conditions elsewhere, prejudice, legal
discrimination, and violence encouraged emigration. Pogroms - violent mob
attacks on Jewish neighbourhoods involving rape, injury, murder, looting and
destruction - began in the Russian Empire in 1881. Jews fled eastern Europe to
many places, including Canada, in the period from the 1880s to the beginning of
WWI. Jews also moved north from the United States, part of the cross-border
migration common in much of Canadian history.
By the time the outbreak of WWI curbed immigration,
there were over 100 000 Jewish Canadians. Montréal and Toronto together
accounted for about three-quarters of the Canadian Jewish population, but Jews
could be found in every major city and in dozens of smaller places. Jews worked
as retailers and wholesalers, many beginning as pedlars and working their way
up to established businesses. Jews also provided much of the labour for the
urban sweatshops of the new ready-to-wear clothing industry. Jewish merchants
spread out to small towns, adding synagogues to the places of worship found in
rural Canada. Eleven Jewish farm colonies were founded in Saskatchewan and
Manitoba, assisted by the Jewish Colonization Society.
Organization and Identity
During their long period of international
dispersion, Jews had developed an identity based on being a national minority
with a distinctive religion and communal structure. When Jews settled in
Canada, they founded organizations which expressed each of these dimensions of
their identity.
In accordance with their religious
traditions of thousands of years (see
Judaism)
places for worship were usually set up soon after the arrival in a new place of
only a handful of families. Often the need to establish a Jewish cemetery was
the source of the first Jewish organization. Synagogues and schools followed
shortly after.
Turn of the century Jewish immigrants came
almost entirely from the multinational empires of eastern Europe. Nationalist
movements (see Nationalism)
within these empires were organizing in pursuit of greater autonomy and
eventual national independence. Modern nationalism encouraged the revival of
Jewish national identity, which took two forms. Each had mass support in
eastern Europe. The first was the movement for the reconstruction of modern
Jewish life around guaranteed minority rights within modern nation-states, with
separate social institutions controlled by the Jewish minority, and the
recognition that the primary language of modern Jewish cultural life would be
the everyday language of eastern European Jews - Yiddish. The second form of
modern Jewish nationalism, Zionism, aimed at the re-establishment of an independent
national state in the ancient Jewish homeland.
Jewish immigrants to Canada from eastern
Europe were sympathetic to both of these movements. The Montreal Jewish Public
Library - one of the major institutions of that community - Yiddish theatres,
and Yiddish literary creativity had their social base in the attachment to
Yiddish culture. The generation of Jews who were being transformed into urban
factory workers were particularly strong supporters of secular Yiddish culture.
The language of their unions and fraternal organizations was Yiddish; through
it they shared and interpreted their experiences in the new land.
The mounting enthusiasm for Zionism in
eastern Europe was paralleled in Canada. The Federation of Canadian Zionist
Societies, founded in 1899 - two years after the first World Zionist Congress -
became the first nation-wide Canadian Jewish organization. Zionism attracted
wide support, including many affluent Jews, who followed the example of
Clarence de Sola, the leader of the Federation of Canadian Zionist Societies,
by joining the movement. The Zionist movement was an important setting where
women's talents were encouraged; women's Zionist organizations took on distinct
projects and produced their own cadre of leaders. By the first decades of the
20th century the Canadian Zionist movement, like Zionism world-wide, also
contained organizations with competing philosophies. Mizrachi blended Zionism with
religious Orthodoxy. Poalei Zion
("the Workers of Zion") had a strong following among the Jewish
working class.
Jewish immigrants also brought a tradition
of establishing a communal body, called a "kehillah," to look after
their social welfare needs. The first Jewish social welfare body in Canada was
the Young Men's Hebrew Benevolent Society, founded in Montréal in 1863 to
assist Jewish immigrants (in recognition of financial support, the name was
changed to the Baron de Hirsch Institute in 1900). Montréal and Toronto, with
large populations, developed a wide range of communal organizations - hospitals,
social work agencies, homes for the aged, libraries and more. There was a
gradual movement towards the formation of organizations to co-ordinate
fundraising in local communities. Immigrant Jews also founded landsmenschaften - literally,
organizations of people from the same place. Landsmenschaften
would sometimes sponsor synagogues, but they were primarily organizations in
which immigrants helped each other and which could reply, as a group, to
appeals for help from those left behind.
The movement to organize the Canadian
Jewish Congress through countrywide elections spoke on behalf of the common
interests of this diverse group of Jews, who thought of themselves in
religious, cultural and communal terms. The Canadian Jewish Congress was
organized in 1919 while the Treaty of Versailles ending WWI was being drafted.
The treatment of national minorities under the new postwar arrangements was of
great interest to Canadian Jews; very many had relatives who were to become
citizens in the newly independent country of Poland. The Congress was also part
of the groundswell of support for Zionism, which had been endorsed by the
British government during WWI and was further endorsed by the new League of
Nations. In anticipation of the renewal of Jewish immigration after the end of
the war, the Congress established the Jewish Immigrant Aid Society, which
continues as a national agency of Canadian Jewry.
The Great Depression and WWII
In 1930 the Canadian government responded
to the unemployment
caused by the beginning of the Depression
by imposing severe restrictions on immigration. Although the cabinet could, and
did, approve certain kinds of immigrants, permission for Jews to enter was
almost never given. Religious intolerance was still a common feature of
Canadian society. Anti-Semitism,
which compounded religious intolerance with the new "science" of
racism, was found among cultural and political leaders (see Prejudice
and Discrimination).
In the face of strong opposition within the
Cabinet and the upper levels of the civil service to admitting Jews, the
Canadian Jewish Congress was reorganized under the leadership of Samuel
Bronfman to work for a safe haven in Canada for some of the increasingly
desperate Jews of Europe. Despite mass protests and continuous lobbying by
political and communal leaders throughout the Depression and war years, pleas
on behalf of the trapped Jews of Europe went unheeded. Canada took in
proportionately fewer Jews than any western country. At the same time, 17 000
Jewish Canadians responded to the call to arms in WWII and served in the armed
forces.
The hard economic times of the Depression
led to a greater awareness of the need to co-ordinate the fundraising for
communal organizations. The level of co-ordination increased in Toronto with
the organization of the United Jewish Welfare Fund in 1937 and in Montréal with
the formation of the Combined Jewish Appeal Campaign in 1941.
The Post-WWII Period
With a growing economy in need of workers,
Canada opened its doors to immigrants soon after the end of WWII. About 40 000
survivors of the Holocaust came in the late 1940s, seeking a peaceful country,
a place where they might have a chance at rebuilding their lives, or simply
coming because they had relatives here. In the 1950s, Jews fleeing hostility in
newly independent countries in North Africa immigrated to Canada, settling
mostly in Montréal, where their French language was an asset.
During the postwar period, Jews became more
fully integrated into Canadian life. Human rights legislation, which began to
be introduced in Canada in the late 1940s, removed discriminatory practices
which had been previously common. The introduction in 1971 of the federal
policy of multiculturalism
(latter supplemented with provincial policies and the incorporation of
multiculturalism into the Canadian Constitution)
highlighted the legitimacy of cultural pluralism within the Canadian mosaic.
Social patterns were also changing as 2nd-
and 3rd-generation Jews born in Canada became a larger part of the community.
Children of immigrant businessmen and labourers persevered through university,
joining the professional ranks of doctors, dentists, accountants, lawyers and
professors. The growth of Canadian cities in the postwar period was accompanied
by the movement of Jews to new suburbs. Rather than dispersing, the 2nd and 3rd
generation of Canadian Jews moved as a group. Synagogues, schools, community
centres and other institutions relocated to these new neighbourhoods.
There was continuing internal Jewish
migration in the postwar period. The Jewish populations of Toronto, Calgary,
Edmonton and Vancouver increased during periods of economic growth. In
contrast, the Jewish population of small towns and rural areas almost disappeared,
with the exception of those small towns within commuting distance of large
cities.
The Contemporary Community
Canada is now home to the 5th-largest
Jewish community in the world - following the US, Israel, the former USSR and
France. Based on 1991 census data the Canadian office of the Council of Jewish
Federations estimated the Canadian Jewish population at approximately 356 000.
This figure includes those who responded "Jewish" to the census
question on religion plus those who responded "no religion" but
indicated Jewish ethnic origin on the census. In the 2006 census, 351 705
people reported being Jewish. The largest number - about 141 700 - were in
Toronto. Despite much talk of a Jewish "exodus," the Jewish
population of Montréal had dropped only slightly, to about 68 500.
The most recent data available indicate
that significant Jewish immigration continues. Data from the 1991 census
indicated that about 30 000 Jews immigrated into Canada from 1981 to 1991.
These immigrants account for over 8% of the Canadian Jewish population, which
roughly corresponds to the percentage of 1981-1991 immigrants in the Canadian
population as a whole. Jewish immigrants from 1981 to 1991 came mainly from the
former USSR, Israel, South Africa and the United States. A continuing small
stream of converts to Judaism also adds to the community. These sources of
population increase may be offset by the disaffiliation of some of the growing
number of Canadians who are of partial Jewish descent.
The generation of survivors of the
Holocaust is now elderly, but the challenge of living with the history of being
the victims of a campaign of mass extermination has not disappeared. The effort
to bring to justice war criminals who had sought refuge in Canada became a
major issue in the 1980s and continues. Remembrance of the Holocaust and the
struggle with its implications are not only personal issues for children and
grandchildren of Holocaust survivors, but also communal issues in Canadian
Jewish life. Museums, lectures and other activities are resources for the
younger generation of Jews and for other Canadians who are troubled about the
threat of another genocide.
The creation of the State of Israel in 1948
marked the success of the Zionist movement and initiated a period of gradually
closer ties between Israelis and Canadian Jews. Jewish federations have
cultivated close relations with Israel, as have the organizations of each of
the branches of Judaism. The Canada-Israel Committee was created to establish
an organization that would speak about Israel on behalf of the Jews in Canada.
Specialized organizations connect Canadian Jews with particular parts of
Israeli society - universities, hospitals, social welfare projects. Visits to
Israel have become much more frequent, often in the form of tours sponsored by
organizations. Most adult Canadian Jews have visited Israel; many have visited
more than once. The number of Canadian Jews who can speak in Hebrew is
increasing.
Jewish federations have moved beyond
meeting social welfare needs, developing co-operative relations with other
community groups, and defending Jews against discrimination and anti-semitism
into activities directly related to Jewish identity and continuity. In
Montréal, a new inclusive body, the Allied Jewish Community Services, was
established in 1965. The Toronto branch of the Canadian Jewish Congress merged
into the United Jewish Welfare Fund in 1976; the new organization is now named
the Jewish Federation of Greater Toronto. In the recent period of governmental
cutbacks in social services, individuals and organizations have looked more for
assistance to the social welfare services supported by Jewish federations. The
12 Jewish communities affiliated with the Canadian office of the Council of
Jewish Federations share responsibility for the Canadian Jewish Congress,
student services at Canadian universities, a Jewish continuity commission, the
Canada-Israel Committee, the Jewish Immigrant Aid Services, a detailed analysis
of census data on Jews and other activities. The Canadian office is recognized
as a regional organization within the North American umbrella organization, the
Council of Jewish Federations.
Jews have made significant contributions to
Canadian culture (see for
literature Jewish
Writing, Leonard
Cohen, A.M.
Klein, Henry
Kreisel, Irving
Layton, Eli
Mandel, Mordecai
Richler, Adele
Wiseman, Miriam
Waddington, Joseph
Rosenblatt, Naim Kattan,
Stuart
Rosenberg, W.
Gunther Plaut; for music: Louis
Applebaum, Milton
Barnes, Alexander
Brott, Harry
Freedman, Srul
Glick, Oskar
Morawetz, John
Weinzweig; in the performance arts: Lloyd
Bochner, Pauline
Donalda, Lorne Greene,
John
Hirsch, Wayne
and Shuster; for journalism: Barbara Frum,
Peter
C. Newman), and have reached responsible positions in public affairs (see David
Barrett, David Croll,
Herb Gray,
Bora
Laskin, David
Lewis, Stephen
Lewis) and in economic life (see
Bronfman
Family, Reichmann
Family, Sam
Steinberg). The present generation of Canadian Jews includes leading
writers, film-makers, musicians, journalists, businessmen, politicians, civil
servants and scholars.
Current theories of ethnic
identity describe ethnic groups as diasporas as well as assimilating
minorities. Diasporas are culturally distinct groups scattered in distant
countries who stay in touch with their homelands and with each other. This
perspective is helpful in understanding Canadian ethnic diversity in general
and Canadian Jews in particular. Jews were historical pioneers in the
development of a long continuing Diaspora way of life. When modern societies
developed in the direction of making ethnic or religious differences issues of
private preference, many Jews chose to make their lives with friends and
spouses outside of their community of origin. With the decreasing significance
of national boundaries, cultural differences and international connections have
again become more important. As well, some Jews, like other people at the end
of the 20th century, have turned to what their tradition says about values in
reaction to the cultural relativism of modern society. Like the members of
other Canadian diasporas, Jews are faced with the challenge of developing
strategies to live in a Canada which is moving towards ever more intimate
involvement with a culturally plural, uncertain and interconnected world.
Suggested Reading
- Irving M. Abella, A Coat of Many Colours: Two Centuries of Jewish Life in Canada (1990); Irving M. Abella and Harold Troper, None Is Too Many: Canada and the Jews of Europe, 1933-1948 (3rd ed 1991); Howard Adelman and John Simpson, eds, Multiculturalism, Jews and Identities in Canada (1995); Ira Robinson, Pierre Anctil and Mervin Butovsky, eds., An Everyday Miracle, Yiddish Culture in Montreal (1991); Gerald Tulchinsky, Taking Root: The Origins of the Canadian Jewish Community (1992).
--------------
PHOTO/PHOTO
David Ben-Gurion (born David Green), Israel’s
first prime minister, trained with hundred of other members of the Jewish
Legion at Fort Edward in the Annapolis Valley in preparation for the British
Army’s plan to liberate Israel from Turkish rule during the First World War. At
right, the 39th Battalion of the Jewish Legion at Fort Edward in Windsor. (ARMY
MUSEUM, HALIFAX CITADEL)
Nova Scotia and the Jews of
the First World War
It’s a world away and more
than a lifetime ago.
The wooden structure still
overlooks the Avon River at Windsor, but nothing suggests the connection
between Fort Edward and the modern-day State of Israel.
Nor is there any sign of a
link between the small rural community at the edge of Nova Scotia’s Annapolis
Valley and the man known as the father of that Jewish state.
But here, almost a century
ago, a Zionist leader arrived with hundreds of other Jewish men to train for
the newly formed Jewish
Legion, a fighting force of
the British Army’s Royal Fusiliers created to liberate Palestine from Turkish
rule during the First World War.
That man was David Ben-Gurion
(born David Green), who would lead the struggle for an independent Jewish state
and, in 1948, become Israel’s first prime minister. He would stay on in that
role until 1953 and become prime minister again from 1961 to 1963.
“In Windsor, one of the great
dreams of my life — to serve as a soldier in a Jewish Unit to fight for the
liberation of the Land of Israel (as we always called Palestine) — became a
reality,” Ben-Gurion wrote in a letter to Windsor’s mayor three years after he
left the prime minister’s job.
“I will never forget Windsor
where I received my first training as a soldier and where I became a corporal.”
It’s a chapter of world
history lost to many.
“I doubt very much most Nova
Scotians know about the Jewish Legion or the connection to Nova Scotia,” said
Ken Hynes, curator of the Army Museum at the Halifax Citadel.
“It’s quite unique … to have
someone (like) that to have been trained here in Nova Scotia, remember Nova
Scotia and to have taken a very prominent place in world history.”
At the Army Museum, the story
of Ben-Gurion and the Jewish Legion connection to Nova Scotia is prominently
displayed in the First World War Centennial Exhibition, The Road to Vimy and
Beyond.
“We wanted to tell the stories
of some soldiers that have been forgotten. The story of the Jewish Legion is
one that hasn’t received much attention, so we want to focus on that as much as
we want to focus on the aboriginal soldiers’ story and the No. 2 Construction
Battalion (mainly African-Canadians),” Hynes said.
An all-Jewish battalion of the
British Army had long been talked about. But it wasn’t until 1917 that four
Jewish battalions — the 38th, 39th, 40th and 42nd — became part of the Royal
Fusiliers. Together, they were known as the Jewish Legion.
The 39th Battalion volunteers,
mostly Americans, were sent to Fort Edward, starting in February 1918. The
troops slept in tents on the hill in the summer and in makeshift barracks in
winter.
The fort, initially used to
train Canadian troops, became the training grounds for non-Canadians
volunteering for the British Army after the Halifax Explosion damaged the
Halifax Armouries.
From there, the troops would
move on to England for more training before heading elsewhere in Europe or to
the Middle East.
According to information provided
by the Army Museum, Ben-Gurion arrived at Fort Edward in June 1918.
“I remember as a kid, somebody
told me Ben-Gurion was here in Nova Scotia during World War 1, but I don’t
think very many people knew that,” recalled Jon Goldberg, executive director of
the Atlantic Jewish Council, a co-sponsor of the museum’s exhibit. “The guy who
told me — I don’t even think he knew why he was here.”
But it’s important information
that shouldn’t be lost to time, Goldberg said.
“It’s Canadian history. A
story like this that happened during the war shows in the long term, over 100
years, there has been directly or indirectly a tie between Israel and Canada.”
FIRST
JEWISH IMMIGRATION TO CANADA
The first Jews immigrated to
Canada in the 1750's. They too had to compromise their Jewish identity in order
to gain entrance into the New World. Canada was under rule of the French
colonizers. So Jews, and in fact all non-Catholics, were prohibited from
settling. Some Jews side-stepped these restrictions by converting to
Catholicism(4). The Gradis family of New France was among the most notable of early Jewish settlers. Historians believe that this Jewish family played a pivotal role in sustaining the colony before it was conquered by the British. The Gradis family had a fleet of ships that went back and forth to France, providing food, supplies and munitions that kept the settlers armed and fed during their fight to defend the colony(5).
But Jewish political allegiances were as varied as anyone else's. While the Gradis family supported the French, a Jewish man by the name of Alexander Shomberg was a commander in the invading British navy. Of course, Schomberg's Jewishness would have been kept secret - only Christians were allowed to serve in the British navy. Schomberg's frigate, Diana, took part in the attack on Quebec that led the battle on the Plains of Abraham, where the French colony fell to British control(6).
The first significant wave of Jewish immigrants to make Canada their home arrived with General Jeffery Amherst in 1760. Most of these Jewish settlers emigrated from the United States and settled in urban centres, the majority in Montreal. The 1831 census recorded 197 Jewish residents in Upper and Lower Canada. By 1851 the number had increased to 451. Most were middle class and well educated; they were involved in trade and contributed to the economic growth of the country(7).
From 1850 to 1900 Jewish immigrants came mostly from Europe(8). During this period approximately 15,000 Jewish immigrants arrived in Canada. The Shumiatcher family, when they came to Canada in 1909, were part of a wave of 120,000 Jews that came from Eastern Europe between 1900 and 1920. Those who came between 1920 and 1940 numbered 60,000 and from WWII to the 1980's, 135,000. The origin of Jewish immigrants at this time was predominantly the United States, North Africa and the Middle East(9).
According to 1991 Census, the Canadian Jewish population today is estimated at 356,000. The largest Jewish populations exist in Toronto, with 162,000, Montreal with 98,000, Vancouver, with 25,000. Jewish immigration to Canada continues: 30,000 Jews entered Canada from 1981 to 1991(10).
ENDNOTES:
4,5,6 - A Coat of Many
Colours, Two Centuries of Jewish Life in Canada, by Irving Abella(Toronto:
Lester & Orpen Dennys Limited, 1990).
7,8
- The Canadian Encyclopedia, James H. Marsh, ed.(Edmonton: Hertig Publishers,
1988)
9,10
- The 1998 Canadian & World Encyclopedia(Toronto: McClelland & Stewart,
1998).
------
1.
[PDF]
1930s when it represented about 1.5% of the total population of Canada.
.... Hitler has done is to clean out the Jews,
that the Jews were possessing Germany ...
whitepinepictures.com/seeds/iii/36/sidebar.html - Cached
In the 1930's, Canada
closed its doors to all immigrants. ... in absorbing farmers, thereby slamming the door on
the vast majority of Austrian and German Jews.
15 Dec 2013 ... It
was 1939 and 907 Jewish refugees aboard the German ... servants
in Ottawa and the widespread
anti-Semitism in Canada during the 1930s.
--------------
NEVER AGAIN...
The Night
of Broken Glass
After the successful conclusion of the Munich
Agreement, many international leaders harbored the hope that Hitler was a
statesman with whom they could continue to negotiate. But on the night of
November 9, 1938, an event occurred which revealed the true nature of Hitler's
regime to the world and also marked the beginning of deadly radicalization of
Nazi policy concerning the Jews.
For some months now, moderate anti-Semites
within the Nazi hierarchy had been losing ground to those favoring extreme
measures such as the immediate removal of Jews from Germany. The subsequent
removal of the first big group of Jews in late October 1938 sparked a chain of
events resulting in the Night of Broken Glass, a massive, coordinated attack on
Jews throughout Greater Germany.
On October 27th, about 17,000 Jews of Polish
origin, including over 2,000 children, were abruptly expelled from Germany on
orders of Reinhard Heydrich, second-in-command of the SS. The Grynszpan family
from the city of Hanover were among the Jews forcibly transported in railroad
cars then dumped at the Polish border as unwanted persons. Polish border
authorities at first denied them permission to enter. The Jews thus ended up in
a kind of no-man's-land between the German and Polish borders.
The Grynszpan family had not taken along their
17-year-old son Herschel. He had gone to Paris for safekeeping at the age of 15
to stay with his uncle who worked there as a tailor. Young Herschel was a
sensitive, somewhat sickly youth who stood just over five feet tall and weighed
about 100 pounds. He was devoutly Orthodox, attended temple regularly, and
strictly observed the various rules of his faith.
Proud of his Jewish heritage, Herschel had a
keen interest in the plight of his family and the half-million Jews still
living in Greater Germany. During his years in Paris he regularly read the
Yiddish newspapers his uncle brought home which chronicled the downward spiral
of "his people" under Nazi control in Germany, Austria and the newly
acquired Sudetenland. The papers also reported the mass expulsion of the Polish
Jews from Germany.
Just before that expulsion, Herschel suffered
a major setback of his own. His request for permanent residency in France was
rejected by local French officials, followed by a decree of expulsion to take
effect on August 15, 1938. Herschel ignored the expulsion decree and remained
in Paris illegally for the time being until he could figure out where to go.
Jews of Polish origin are abruptly expelled
from Germany in late October 1938 - allowed to take a suitcase and little else
- then taken by train and dumped at the Polish border with nowhere to go.
Below: Portrait of Herschel Grynszpan in jail after his arrest.
Below: A crowd watches as a temple is allowed
to burn while only the surrounding structures are hosed down by German
firefighters.
Below: A smashed plate-glass window and looted
contents of a Jewish-owned shop in Berlin.
Below: Jewish men at Baden-Baden in Germany
are marched off under heavy guard to a concentration camp - marking the advent
of Nazi mass roundups of Jews.
He had become, like his family, a man without
a country, unwanted anywhere because of his Jewish ancestry. Herschel sank into
deep depression at this turn of events and even considered suicide. Making
matters worse, he then received a letter from his family describing the ordeal
of their expulsion from Germany.
His 22-year-old sister, Esther, wrote:
"You undoubtedly heard of our great misfortune. I will describe to you
what happened...On Thursday evening at 9 o'clock a Sipo [Nazi security
policeman] came to us and informed us that we had to go to police headquarters
and bring along our passports...We were not told what it was all about, but we
saw that everything was finished for us. Each of us had an extradition order
pressed into his hand, and one had to leave Germany before the 29th. They
didn't permit us to return home anymore. I asked to be allowed to go home to
get at least a few things. I went, accompanied by a Sipo, and packed the
necessary clothes in a suitcase. And that is all I saved. We don't have a
penny..."
His father had spent the past 28 years
building up a modest tailoring business in Hanover.
Driven half-mad with sorrow and anger over all
that was happening, Herschel decided to commit a radical act of violence to
draw the world's attention to the plight of the Jews.
On Monday morning, November 7, he walked into
a Paris gun shop and purchased a 6.35-caliber revolver along with a box of 25
bullets. When the shop owner asked why he wanted the gun, Herschel answered
that he sometimes carried large amounts of money for his father and needed the
protection.
After buying the gun, Herschel walked to a
nearby café, entered the restroom there and loaded it, then put the gun in his
left coat pocket. He took the Paris subway to the German embassy, arriving at
9:35 a.m. He entered the building and asked the first person he encountered,
the wife of the concierge, if he could see an embassy official concerning some
important papers he wanted to submit. He was pointed toward a flight of stairs
and told to see a Herr Nagorka, the clerk-receptionist, up there.
Upstairs, Herschel told Nagorka he had an
important document he wanted to hand-deliver to an embassy official. Nagorka
offered to deliver the document for him, but Herschel insisted he had to
deliver it himself because of its importance. This is how he wound up in the
office of 29-year-old Secretary of Legation, Ernst vom Rath, who was the most
junior embassy official on duty that morning.
Vom Rath seated Herschel, took his own seat
nearby, then asked to see the document. Herschel responded to his request by
shouting: "You're a filthy Kraut and in the name of the twelve-thousand
persecuted Jews, here is the document!"
Herschel reached into his coat pocket, took
out the gun, and blasted away at vom Rath, shooting five shots wildly, striking
vom Rath twice as he stood up. The first bullet lodged in vom Rath's left
shoulder and did little damage. The second bullet struck him in the lower left
side, causing severe internal damage.
Herschel dropped the empty gun to the floor.
The wounded vom Rath gave Herschel a quick smack with his fist, then dashed
toward the door, clutching his abdomen and calling out for help. Herschel never
left the office but just waited to be arrested. He was taken into custody by
Nagorka and another embassy worker. At Herschel's request he was then handed
over to the French police.
Vom Rath was rushed to the hospital where he
underwent emergency surgery to remove his ruptured spleen, and to repair damage
to his stomach and pancreas. Despite the surgery and massive blood
transfusions, vom Rath suffered from a very high fever and gradually weakened
until he expired at 4:25 p.m., Wednesday, November 9th.
While this was occurring, Adolf Hitler and
most of the highest ranking Nazis were in Munich for the annual re-enactment of
the Beer Hall Putsch. Every year on November 9, veterans of the 1923 Putsch
gathered to retrace the same steps they had taken in their failed attempt to
overthrow Germany's democratic government. The day was also a national holiday
known as the Day of the Movement with Germans enjoying a day off from work and
kids staying home from school.
Upon first hearing of the shooting incident,
Hitler had sent his own personal physician to Paris to aid vom Rath. Propaganda
Minister Joseph Goebbels, meanwhile, instantly recognized the shooting as a
golden opportunity. Goebbels was by now the most powerful anti-Semite in the
Nazi hierarchy, second only to Hitler. The little man with the club foot, who
had been teased about his own so-called Jewish looks as a youth, harbored a
life-long, deep-seated hatred for Jews. For five years now, Goebbels'
propaganda machine had been spewing out a never-ending stream of messages
portraying Jews as the mortal enemy of the German people. For Goebbels, the shooting
in Paris was a chance to incite the German people to "rise in bloody
vengeance against the Jews."
Goebbels, of course, wouldn't do anything
without his Führer's approval. In the early evening hours of November 9, a
messenger arrived bearing news of vom Rath's death just as Hitler and his old
cronies were about to sit down to a festive dinner at Old City Hall in Munich,
following a long day of self-congratulations, pomp and Nazi pageantry. Upon
being told of vom Rath's demise, an angry looking Hitler took Goebbels aside
and conferred privately for several minutes, finally telling Goebbels the SA
storm troopers should have a "fling" at the expense of the Jews.
After dinner, Hitler left the hall without
making a speech, leaving Goebbels to deliver the actual marching orders to the
assembled Nazi leadership. Goebbels first announced vom Rath's death, then
launched into an anti-Semitic diatribe, prompting the SA and Nazi Party leaders
to incite a popular uprising against Jews throughout Greater Germany without
making it look like the Nazi Party was the actual instigator.
When Goebbels finished his remarks, most of
the assembled leaders headed for the nearest telephone to call their local SA
and Party offices to deliver the appropriate instructions. However, the nuance
of Goebbels message somehow got lost amid all of the telephone conversations.
As a result, uniformed Brownshirts and Party activists carrying swastika
banners took to the streets instead of nondescript civilians.
In fact, the popular uprising Hitler and
Goebbels hoped to ignite never materialized. Most civilians either pulled down
their window shades and stayed inside or stood silently on the sidewalk along
with the regular German police and watched as storm troopers, SS men and Hitler
Youth, accompanied by miscellaneous street punks, broke into Jewish homes, beat
up and murdered Jewish men and terrorized Jewish women and children.
All over Germany and Austria that evening,
Jewish shops and department stores had their windows smashed and contents
wrecked. Synagogues were especially targeted for vandalism, including
desecration of sacred Torah scrolls which were unraveled and tossed into a pile
then burned.
Hundreds of synagogues went up in flames while
fire fighters stood by watching or simply hosed down surrounding buildings to
prevent the fire from spreading. Nearly all Jewish cemeteries near the
synagogues were also desecrated.
About 25,000 Jewish men were hauled off to
Dachau, Buchenwald and Sachsenhausen concentration camps where they were
brutalized by SS guards and in some cases randomly chosen to be beaten to
death. In all, it is estimated that up to 2,500 Jews perished from beatings on
the street, incarceration in the camps, and from the numerous suicides that
occurred, including entire families.
The many thousands of broken plate-glass
windows resulted in the term Kristallnacht or Night of Broken Glass to describe
the events of November 9th lasting into the early morning hours of the 10th.
Although the Nazis didn't get the popular uprising they had hoped for, they did
notice that the overall population of some 60 million Germans showed remarkable
indifference toward this first mass persecution of the Jews. Those who were
shocked or outraged knew enough to keep their thoughts to themselves or risk
being sent to a concentration camp.
Outside of Germany, however, the shock and
outrage were not silenced. Radio commentators and newspaper writers in the
United States declared that Germany had descended to a level of barbarism unseen
since the pogroms of the Middle Ages.
The storm of negative worldwide publicity
served to isolate Hitler's Germany from the civilized nations of the West and
weakened any pro-Nazi sentiments in those countries. Before Kristallnacht,
small pro-Hitler movements existed in both Britain and the U.S. After
Kristallnacht, sympathy for the Hitler regime gradually evaporated. The United
States also permanently recalled its ambassador from Germany.
However, radical anti-Semites within the Nazi
hierarchy didn't care what the world thought. A few days after Kristallnacht,
on November 12th, a dozen top Nazis including Joseph Goebbels, Reinhard
Heydrich, and Hermann Göring, gathered to discuss what happened and to decide
on further measures.
Heydrich reported 7,500 Jewish businesses
destroyed, 267 synagogues burned (with 177 totally destroyed) and 91 Jews
murdered during Kristallnacht. Heydrich then requested new decrees forbidding
Jews from having any social contact with Germans by excluding them from public
transportation, schools, and hospitals, essentially forcing them into ghettos
or out of the country. Goebbels said the Jews would be made to clean out the
debris from burned-out synagogues which would then be demolished and turned
into parking lots.
At this meeting there was a general agreement
to eliminate Jews entirely from economic life in the Reich by transferring all
Jewish property and enterprises to non-Jews, with minor compensation to be
given to the Jews in the form of German bonds.
Regarding the economic damage from
Kristallnacht and the resulting massive insurance claims, Göring declared the
Jews themselves should be billed for the damage and that any insurance money
payable to them should be confiscated by the Government.
"I shall close the meeting with these
words," said Göring, "German Jewry shall, as punishment for their
abominable crimes, et cetera, have to make a contribution for one billion
marks. That will work. The swine won't commit another murder. Incidentally, I
would like to say that I would not like to be a Jew in Germany."
As for Herschel Grynszpan, he was interrogated
by the French police and declared: "It was not with hatred or for
vengeance against any particular person that I acted, but because of love for
my parents and for my people who were unjustly subjected to outrageous
treatment. Nevertheless, this act was distasteful to me and I deeply regret it.
However, I had no other means of demonstrating my feelings...It is not, after
all, a crime to be Jewish. I am not a dog. I have the right to live. My people
have a right to exist on this earth. And yet everywhere they are hunted down
like animals."
Herschel eventually wound up in the clutches
of the Gestapo and spent time in various Nazi prisons and concentration camps,
and vanished without a trace.
------------------------------
SWITZERLAND'S HATE OF JEWS...
The Red Cross should stick to helping
people in need, not waste resources in bashing Israel
THE ICRC (SWISS... INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE OF
THE RED CROSS).... AND THEIR WAR AGAINST ISRAEL...
For nearly four decades many in the
international community have insisted that Jews are forbidden to live in Judea,
Samaria and Gaza (Yesha), 'eastern Jerusalem,' and the Golan - areas conquered
by Israel in 1967. Leading this fight was and is a private Swiss organization,
the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).
The ICRC was the first international
organization to charge that "the presence of Israeli settlements in the
occupied territories is contrary to the Geneva Convention," and therefore
"unlawful."
"Any measure designed to expand or
consolidate settlements is also illegal. Confiscation of land to build or
expand settlements is similarly prohibited." (ICRC, 2009)
And the world listens, because the ICRC isn't
just another NGO; it is the official recognized authority on the Fourth Geneva
Convention (GC IV). Its decisions, therefore, were and are crucial in
determining international law and vilifying Israel. Every judicial condemnation
of Israel cites the GC and follows ICRC's interpretation.
This explains why the international community
and courts have accepted ICRC's decisions that "Israeli (Jewish)
settlements violate international law" without question.
Based on The Hague Convention, GC IV was drawn
up after WWII to protect innocent civilians and restrict brutal occupations.
Unilaterally, the ICRC turned it into a weapon to delegitimize and demonize
Israel. Meeting secretly in the early 1970's in Geneva, the ICRC determined
that Israel was in violation of the GC IV. That's been "the law" ever
since.
And there's no appeal, because all decisions
and protocols of the ICRC are closed, even the identities of the people
involved are secret. Without transparency or due process, ICRC rulings became
"international law." Their condemnations of Israel provide the sole
basis for accusing Israel of "illegal occupation" of all territory
conquered in 1967.
It's a legal fraud.
Article 49 of GC IV says: "The Occupying
Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into
the territory it occupies."
According to the ICRC, this forbids Jews from
living in Judea, Samaria, Golan and eastern Jerusalem - areas conquered by
Israel in 1967 - even though they moved there voluntarily, and prohibits any
form of government assistance to them, including roads, utilities, schools and
clinics.
The ICRC's position contradicts all written
agreements which confirm the right of Jews to live in their ancestral homeland
- League of Nations and British Mandate - including the Oslo Accords.
Article 49 obviously refers to the territory
of another country, or sovereign power; Judea, Samaria and Gaza don't fit this
definition. These areas were illegally occupied by Jordan and Egypt between
1948 and 1967; the ICRC, of course, differs, but has never satisfactorily
answered the question to which State this territory belongs.
Holding these territories in limbo for a
future Palestinian state, which may never come to fruition, whose borders are
undefined and whose intentions are openly hostile is absurd. Such ICRC
antagonism to Israel, however, is pervasive.
During WW II the ICRC visited concentration
camps and gave the Nazis a pass. After the war, they provided false passports
to escaping Nazi war criminals.
Their website demonstrates their humanitarian
efforts around the world, but when it comes to the Middle East, their story is
one-sided. During two decades of constant terrorist attacks against Israeli
civilians, the ICRC said nothing. They have written several stories about the
suffering of "Palestinians" in Gaza and Lebanon as a result of
Israeli actions, without mentioning terrorist attacks that prompted a response.
The ICRC condemned IDF actions to stop
terrorism in Jenin, Lebanon and Gaza as "massacres." They have
consistently condemned Israel for 'violations of Palestinian civil and human
rights,' and accused Israel of "war crimes." Sometimes, when these
lies were exposed, the ICRC has recanted - but not often and never with full
disclosure.
Because the ICRC lacks transparency, there's
no way to find out how and why they made their decisions, or who made them. If
they have nothing to hide, why the secrecy?
The Red Cross should stick to helping people
in need, not waste resources in bashing Israel.
and heeeeeeeeeeeeeereeeeeeeeeeee's their
website:
... OMG!!!!!
By the by... hasn't Switzerland been taken to
task for their actions against the Jews... the war where over 6 MILLION JEWS
WERE MURDERED... along with Catholics, Gypsies and persons because of race,
colour, creed and sexual orientation.... that war? No more hiding.... let's
" get r done!"
------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.